# Rethinking Covert Stuttering

**Constantino, Manning & Nordstrom (2017) · Passing as resistance, not repression**

*Constantino, Manning & Nordstrom · Primary Research · Power & Equity, Voice & Silence · Journal of Fluency Disorders · 2017 · Paywalled*

Constantino, Manning and Nordstrom contest the framing of covert stuttering, or passing as fluent, as an inherently negative pursuit: the repression of an authentic, stuttering self. Working from Michel Foucault's ethics, they ask how a person must relate to herself in order to pass, and conclude that their data suggest passing is more usefully understood as a form of resistance by people who stutter to a hostile society. Covert stuttering, they argue, is not inauthentic stuttering but stuttering produced through specific 'technologies of communication'.

The study rests on semi-structured interviews, averaging 106 minutes, with nine adults who self-identified as passing as fluent, recruited through self-help groups and an online group for people who covertly stutter. Both interview guide and analysis followed Foucault's four components of ethics. The aim was new meanings, not population inferences, which the small sample and lack of a control group would make impossible.

All nine described 'direct delegitimization', such as mockery or being refused a job, and 'indirect delegitimization': listeners finishing their sentences, advice to slow down, a look of discomfort, silence from loved ones, and therapy programmes claiming a cure, which implied that anyone still stuttering was at fault. Participants said altruism and sympathy were often just as disabling as mocking. The practices of passing, from predicting stutters to substituting words and avoiding situations, were mostly intentional and active, and much of it resembled therapy techniques known to increase fluency. For all nine the main goal was what the paper calls 'able-bodied privilege'. Avoidance was often subtle, such as not taking part as fully as they would have liked, and at other times flagrant: one participant skipped work meetings.

Two thirds of participants were women, though, on earlier estimates they cite, roughly four times as many adult men as women stutter; they caution that selection may have biased the sample. They acknowledge that the interviews, all conducted by Constantino, were shaped by his subjectivity and his reading of Foucault. Clinically, they suggest a person who stutters might work on avoidance of stuttering, or effort and struggle, rather than on stuttering itself.

The paper does not discuss psychological safety; the bridge is ours. We read indirect delegitimisation as an account of how well-meant listening, finishing a sentence or advising calm, can teach a speaker that their way of speaking is illegitimate, and passing as work, unseen by the listener, done to gain what the paper calls able-bodied privilege.

- **Citation:** Constantino, C.D., Manning, W.H. and Nordstrom, S.N. (2017) 'Rethinking covert stuttering', Journal of Fluency Disorders, 53, pp. 26-40.
- **This page:** https://explore.psychsafety.com/n/constantino-manning-nordstrom-2017/
- **View the source paper:** https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jfludis.2017.06.001
- **Interactive map:** https://explore.psychsafety.com/?mode=papers&node=constantino-manning-nordstrom-2017

## Neighbours (7)

- [How We Respond](https://explore.psychsafety.com/n/how-we-respond-matters.md)
- [Not Same for Everyone](https://explore.psychsafety.com/n/psychological-safety-isnt-the-same-for-everyone.md)
- [Forced Vulnerability](https://explore.psychsafety.com/n/forced-vulnerability.md)
- [Accessibility & PS](https://explore.psychsafety.com/n/accessibility-a-road-to-psychological-safety.md)
- [Stuttering & Stammering](https://explore.psychsafety.com/n/stuttering-and-stammering.md)
- [Stuttering and the social model](https://explore.psychsafety.com/n/constantino-campbell-simpson-2022.md) (paper)
- [The Construction of the Disabled Speaker: Locating Stuttering in Disability Studies](https://explore.psychsafety.com/n/st-pierre-2012.md) (paper)
