# 'All of the White People Went First': How Video Conferencing Consolidates Control and Exacerbates Workplace Bias

**Houtti et al (2023) · Video calls concentrate meeting control**

*Houtti et al · Primary Research · Power & Equity, Voice & Silence · Proceedings of the ACM on Human-Computer Interaction · 2023 · Open access*

Houtti, Zhou, Terveen and Chancellor ask how video conferencing contributes to bias in workplace meetings, counting a system as biased if it 'systematically imposes inequitable costs or barriers to participation'. Their answer is that it 'pushes meeting leaders to take on excess control over core meeting parameters': technically, as when a host alone decides whether to record, and socially, sometimes through ambiguity about how features should be used.

The evidence is 22 semi-structured Zoom interviews in October and November 2021 with professionals reached through contacts and snowball sampling; when a first round proved largely white and Asian, a second sought people from under-represented minority groups. Two researchers coded the transcripts into about 1,700 open codes, then grouped them by axial coding.

The findings are what participants reported. Several noticed that tiles sit in a different order on each screen; the paper argues this stops a group going round the circle, leaving the leader to choose who speaks. The title is a participant's words: P11 recalled a manager whose calling order meant 'all of the white people went first before any of the people of color', which she did not think intentional, adding that similar dynamics had played out in person. Participants reported being more engaged with cameras on, and said people with cameras on were more often brought in and shown first, and said raise hand was typically not used unless a leader encouraged it. Chat, when encouraged and properly incorporated, was reported to lower barriers to participation, though people often rely on leaders to acknowledge it. Hosts control recording and rarely ask consent; the most common reaction described was turning cameras off. The paper calls recording a double-edged sword: one participant was repeatedly misgendered in a recorded meeting, another valued recordings for people with cognitive disabilities.

They propose transferring control from meeting leaders to technical systems or other attendees, and helping leaders better exercise the control they hold. Named limits: English-speaking, almost all US-based workplaces, a snowball sample with many in technology, and broad aims rather than one marginalised group. Cisco Research funded the work.

Psychological safety appears once, in a participant's words: P2 said adding a chat comment 'feels really easy' and 'I think it feels like there's a lot more psychological safety in being able to add your opinions'. The bridge is ours: we read the study as showing how a meeting tool's design can put who gets heard in the hands of whoever runs the meeting.

- **Citation:** Houtti, M., Zhou, M., Terveen, L. and Chancellor, S. (2023) '"All of the White People Went First": How Video Conferencing Consolidates Control and Exacerbates Workplace Bias', Proceedings of the ACM on Human-Computer Interaction, 7(CSCW1), Article 121, pp. 1–25.
- **This page:** https://explore.psychsafety.com/n/houtti-et-al-2023/
- **View the source paper:** https://arxiv.org/abs/2212.00849
- **Interactive map:** https://explore.psychsafety.com/?mode=papers&node=houtti-et-al-2023

## Neighbours (8)

- [Gender Inequality in Deliberative Participation](https://explore.psychsafety.com/n/karpowitz-mendelberg-shaker-2012.md) (paper)
- [Not Same for Everyone](https://explore.psychsafety.com/n/psychological-safety-isnt-the-same-for-everyone.md)
- [Psychologically Safe Meetings](https://explore.psychsafety.com/n/six-ways-to-run-psychologically-safe-meetings.md)
- [Scientific Medical Conferences Can Be Easily Modified to Improve Female Inclusion: A Prospective Study](https://explore.psychsafety.com/n/salem-et-al-2021.md) (paper)
- [Speaking Up at Work](https://explore.psychsafety.com/n/speaking-up-at-work.md)
- [Evidence-based recommendations for recorded-meetings policies](https://explore.psychsafety.com/n/carradini-et-al-2024.md) (paper)
- [PS in Remote Teams](https://explore.psychsafety.com/n/psychological-safety-in-remote-teams.md)
- [Verbally Speaking Up](https://explore.psychsafety.com/n/verbally-speaking-up-at-work.md)
