# Silence That Can Be Dangerous: A Vignette Study to Assess Healthcare Professionals' Likelihood of Speaking up about Safety Concerns

**Schwappach & Gehring (2014) · Voice varies by vignette**

*Schwappach & Gehring · Primary Research · Voice & Silence, Safety & Error, Power & Equity · PLoS ONE · 2014 · Open access*

Shows that whether clinicians say they would speak up about a colleague's error depends heavily on the situation, and that staff without managerial roles find it more uncomfortable. In Schwappach and Gehring's survey, 1,013 nurses and doctors in Swiss oncology (a 65% response rate) rated four vignettes of a coworker's error or safety rule violation: an errant prescription, a missed hand disinfection, a skipped double check in medication preparation and a lumbar puncture without fresh coagulation results. Each came in eight versions, varying three of seven binary attributes standing for power differentials, public versus private settings, repetition, negligence and harm.

Stated willingness was high on average, 81% of vignette ratings above the scale midpoint, but the share who said they would speak up ranged from 45% to 96% by incident and version. Seniority did not act uniformly. Respondents were less likely to speak up to a senior physician than to a resident in the lumbar puncture case, but whether a head nurse or nurses skipped the double check made no significant difference, contrary to their hypothesis. Several staff present lowered the likelihood of questioning a senior physician's prescription; an attentive patient, and a senior physician rather than a head nurse, lowered it for missed hand hygiene; a violation already raised once before lowered it for the double check, though not in the lumbar puncture case. Managerial staff had lower odds of reporting discomfort (odds ratio 0.55) and decision difficulty (0.52). Managerial staff also had higher odds of saying they would speak up (1.71), but in the full regression (909 respondents, 3,636 vignette ratings), which also held the harm, discomfort and difficulty ratings with age, profession and other traits, managerial function was not a significant predictor, which Schwappach and Gehring read as staff without it being 'not per se hesitant to speak up', held back instead by the 'difficult emotions connected to the behavior'. Perceived harm predicted speaking up, but its effect 'only slightly exceeded' that of discomfort, and decision difficulty carried the largest coefficient of the three ratings.

Speaking up was anticipated, not observed, so estimates are likely subject to 'hypotheticality and social desirability bias'; time pressure and relationships could not be simulated; nurses were 780 of the 1,013 and overrepresented by the sampling, and representativeness cannot be estimated. They suggest that adapting to rule violations which persist despite challenge may spread to a 'culture of silence', They recommend clear guidance and training on when and how to voice concerns, and say the results should be 'confirmed in further research' before being used to design training.

The paper does not name psychological safety, so the bridge is ours: we read its discomfort and decision difficulty ratings as close to the interpersonal risk the construct names, and its warning that leaders' own perception of speaking up 'is likely to differ' from that of lower status staff as a reason not to judge a team's safety by its senior members.

- **Citation:** Schwappach, D.L.B. and Gehring, K. (2014) 'Silence that can be dangerous: a vignette study to assess healthcare professionals' likelihood of speaking up about safety concerns', PLoS ONE, 9(8), e104720.
- **This page:** https://explore.psychsafety.com/n/schwappach-gehring-2014/
- **View the source paper:** https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0104720
- **Interactive map:** https://explore.psychsafety.com/?mode=papers&node=schwappach-gehring-2014

## Neighbours (9)

- [Calculus of Voice](https://explore.psychsafety.com/n/the-calculus-of-voice.md)
- [Speaking Up in the Operating Room: How Team Leaders Promote Learning in Interdisciplinary Action Teams](https://explore.psychsafety.com/n/edmondson-2003b.md) (paper)
- [Employee Voice Behavior: Integration and Directions for Future Research](https://explore.psychsafety.com/n/morrison-2011.md) (paper)
- [Error, stress, and teamwork in medicine and aviation: cross sectional surveys](https://explore.psychsafety.com/n/sexton-thomas-helmreich-2000.md) (paper)
- [Psychological Safety in Healthcare](https://explore.psychsafety.com/n/psychological-safety-in-healthcare.md)
- [Reducing Power Gradients](https://explore.psychsafety.com/n/reducing-power-gradients.md)
- [Speaking Up at Work](https://explore.psychsafety.com/n/speaking-up-at-work.md)
- [Checklists and Monitoring in the Cockpit: Why Crucial Defenses Sometimes Fail](https://explore.psychsafety.com/n/dismukes-berman-2010.md) (paper)
- [Verbally Speaking Up](https://explore.psychsafety.com/n/verbally-speaking-up-at-work.md)
