# The Paradox of Resilience and Efficiency

**van Staveren (2023) · Community economy combines resilience, efficiency**

*van Staveren · Commentary · Commons & Governance, Ecological · Journal of Economic Issues · 2023 · Open access*

Irene van Staveren asks whether it is possible to have more resilience in a capitalist economy, when resilience and efficiency 'tend to be regarded as trade-offs'. After Roger Martin (2019), she notes that resilience seems to demand a sacrifice of efficiency because it requires slack. Ecology and the study of the commons, she writes, indicate that when we rely more on cooperation and less on competition, resilience and efficiency 'may go hand in hand'.

From Ostrom's commons research and the resilience-building principles of Berbés-Blázquez and colleagues (2022), she sorts the institutions of resilience into three types: boundary institutions, diversity institutions, and redundancy, or buffers. Ostrom, she notes, found redundancy in the monitoring of commons, which helps to crowd in trust; such redundancy, she adds, is not costly because it is set up as self-reinforcing.

After Knight, Keynes and Minsky on uncertainty and buffers, she contrasts two views: from a linear efficiency perspective in a world without uncertainty, buffers are regarded as costs, or slack; from a resilience perspective that acknowledges uncertainty, they are investments in long-term adaptation where insurance is not possible. Boundary institutions, she suggests, may be more efficient than unconstrained markets, and for diversity she invokes Ashby's law of requisite variety, by way of de Raadt (1987), and two reviews of board diversity and performance.

Following Marx, she argues that resilience does not fit well with capitalist production, where competition forces short-termism and efficiency is sought only internally and in the short run. The community economy, as in worker co-operatives, commons and mutual insurers, combines economic roles through cooperation and reciprocity. Research, she writes, indicates that such activities tend to be both resilient and successful, which implies they are quite efficient, with that efficiency focused on the long term. She concludes that the opposition between resilience and efficiency is part and parcel of capitalism but not necessarily a feature of non-capitalist economic activity; her abstract goes further, saying the two can be combined only in the community economy and outside capitalism. She presents no new data and states no limitations; her evidence on co-operatives and boards is that of the studies she cites.

Nothing in it concerns teams or psychological safety; the bridge is ours. We read her two views of a buffer, as slack to be cut or as an investment against uncertainty, as the choice an organisation makes about spare capacity in its teams.

- **Citation:** van Staveren, I. (2023) 'The paradox of resilience and efficiency', Journal of Economic Issues, 57(3), pp. 808-813.
- **This page:** https://explore.psychsafety.com/n/van-staveren-2023/
- **View the source paper:** https://doi.org/10.1080/00213624.2023.2237861
- **Interactive map:** https://explore.psychsafety.com/?mode=papers&node=van-staveren-2023

## Neighbours (3)

- [Governing the Commons: The Evolution of Institutions for Collective Action](https://explore.psychsafety.com/n/ostrom-1990.md) (paper)
- [Efficiency vs Resilience](https://explore.psychsafety.com/n/efficiency-vs-resilience.md)
- [Queueing Theory & Slack](https://explore.psychsafety.com/n/queueing-theory-slack-and-resilience.md)
