Psych Safety, by Iterum

Evidence-based recommendations for recorded-meetings policies

Carradini et al (2024) · Consent, candour and recorded meetings

Carradini et al · Commentary · Voice & Silence, Trust & Interpersonal · Business Horizons · 2024 · Paywalled

Open this neighbourhood on the live map →

Carradini and colleagues argue that recorded virtual meetings need explicit policies, because the benefits of recording (faster, wider information sharing, searchable transcripts) come with drawbacks that bear on candour: harder discussion of sensitive or controversial positions, threats to privacy, little ability to go off the record, and unease about who will eventually watch. Their central recommendation is that managers co-create policy preferences with employees in 'open-ended and nonjudgmental' conversations, then hand them to a team from HR, IT and the executive, with legal review, to draft and deliver the policy.

The evidence is a survey of 428 frequent participants in virtual meetings across a range of company sizes and sectors; its breakdowns by role, company size and sector each come to 427. The paper does not say when or where it ran, how respondents were recruited or how its questions were worded, and it reports descriptive percentages without statistical tests. Just over half (50.7%) said their organisation had a recording policy. Among those whose companies had or wanted a policy, consent was the topic most often marked as included and as desired. Of people in daily external meetings, 72% thought policies increase legal compliance, against 56% of those meeting externally weekly or less.

Psychological safety, defined in Edmondson's 1999 wording, is described as harder to establish in virtual meetings. They report that policies 'are accepted more readily in psychologically safe workplaces': in high safety environments respondents saw them as helpful for legal compliance (92%), team trust (84%), efficiency (80%) and meeting effectiveness (78%). Safety was binned from five proxy questions into relative categories, and figures for the lower groups are not given, so the comparison behind 'more readily' is not shown. On this they argue that safety is 'an important antecedent' to accepting such policies, and advise building it first. Consent, they say, shows this directly: someone refusing to be recorded must be confident it will not bring 'adverse social or professional consequences', yet, citing Houtti and colleagues, refusing is often difficult in practice. They suggest 24 hours' notice that a meeting will be recorded.

Respondents preferred the policy to come from IT (33.8%), the executive team (30%) or HR (20%) rather than their own manager (1.9%), on about 210 answers. The rest is guidance: a 2x2 framework weighing the value of documenting against risks that include security, privacy and psychological safety, and a default of following the strictest jurisdiction an organisation works in. The paper has no limitations section; the caveat it gives on its evidence is that the safety categories are relative, not absolute.

Carradini, S., Getchell, K., Cardon, P., Fleischmann, C., Aritz, J. and Stapp, J. (2024) 'Evidence-based recommendations for recorded-meetings policies', Business Horizons, 67(1), pp. 83–92.

Save this paper to a bibliography, keep notes on it, and export citations. Create a free account →

Related psychsafety.com articles (3)

Related papers (3)

View the source paper →