Psych Safety, by Iterum

Stuttering and the social model

Constantino, Campbell & Simpson (2022) · Fluency norms as disabling barriers

Constantino, Campbell & Simpson · Theoretical · Power & Equity, Voice & Silence, Critique & Boundary · Journal of Communication Disorders · 2022 · Paywalled

Open this neighbourhood on the live map →

A discussion paper that applies the social model of disability to stuttering, then weighs its limits. Constantino, Campbell and Simpson take from Oliver the view that disability is the result of environmental barriers rather than an individual's impairment, and argue that although the model does not explain why people stutter, it does help explain why stuttering is experienced the way it is. Under that lens, they write, the challenges of stuttering have little to do with disfluency and everything to do with living with a stigmatised trait that society does not accommodate, and a vicious cycle follows: a person stutters, meets discrimination, blames the stutter, and tries their hardest not to stutter again. Citing an earlier qualitative study by Constantino and colleagues, they hold that people who stutter pass as fluent to access able-bodied privilege.

There are no new data; the argument runs through the stuttering literature, disability theory and a worked example, the job interview. Time-limited interviews, they argue, disable disfluent candidates; employers can see people who stutter as a poor fit for jobs involving verbal communication, and self-stigma may lead some to judge themselves unsuitable (both after Butler, 2014). At the interview itself, avoidance strategies can lead people to choose non-preferred words, abandon sentences, or not speak at all. Drawing on St. Pierre (2012), they suggest stuttering's liminal status, with the stigma attached to disability, helps explain a reluctance to identify as disabled, which is disabling in itself because reasonable adjustments go unsought. They propose work on law, media and research, and a therapy that shifts the focus from 'what is wrong with me' to 'what is wrong with the broader system in which I live', noting that best practice for inclusion is largely anecdotal rather than evidence based.

They then turn on the model. Most critiques target its strict separation of biological impairment from social disability. Many people who stutter, they note, still struggle to speak even with others who stutter, and the model does appear, they concede, to have problems meeting these critiques. People who stutter have accused it of putting them at the mercy of society and robbing them of agency. They conclude that it is neither perfect nor complete but an important first step, and point to relational models, neurodiversity and stuttering gain. All three co-edited an anthology applying the model to stuttering, a declared competing interest.

The paper does not discuss psychological safety; the bridge is ours. We read the interview example as an account of edited voice, with words swapped, sentences dropped and silence chosen to avoid stigma, and the critique as a reminder that removing social barriers can lower the cost of speaking without removing all of its effort.

Constantino, C., Campbell, P. and Simpson, S. (2022) 'Stuttering and the social model', Journal of Communication Disorders, 96, 106200.

Save this paper to a bibliography, keep notes on it, and export citations. Create a free account →

Related psychsafety.com articles (4)

Related papers (3)

View the source paper →