Whistle-blowing and workplace culture in older peoples' care: qualitative insights from the healthcare and social care workforce
Jones & Kelly (2014) · Beyond whistle-blowing or silence
Following Teo and Caspersz, Aled Jones and Daniel Kelly argue that research and policy have framed whistle-blowing in care as a choice between blowing the whistle and staying silent, a dichotomy that hides a spectrum of alternative kinds of behaviour staff may use. Drawing on Turner on man-made disasters, Vaughan's normalisation of deviance and the 'deaf effect' of those in authority reluctant to hear bad news, they raise the possibility that staff 'are not silent in the face of wrongdoing' but 'may raise concerns internally that are often ignored'.
The qualitative study, funded by the Older People's Commissioner for Wales, ran in Wales in 2012 with 60 participants from nursing and residential homes, two older people's wards in a large NHS teaching hospital and domiciliary care, and four, by telephone, from the regulator and the police. The paper's table counts 17 registered nurses, 23 care assistants, 16 second year nursing students and four regulator and police representatives, seen in individual interviews and three focus groups and analysed thematically.
Most participants disliked the term whistle-blowing, some likening it to 'grassing'. Managers described role-modelling openness, and all suggested regular team meetings. Most said their response depended on perceived severity: severe physical harm would go, without hesitation, to senior staff or external agencies; less serious lapses drew 'having a word' or 'taking them to one side', students asking 'is that okay?', and humour. These exchanges go unrecorded, which they suggest 'may well be one reason' an organisation appears silent once the spotlight turns on it. Participants did not refer to professional codes, relying on personal values. One manager described how 'the abnormal becomes the normal', another how shouting at residents 'just crept in'; longer serving staff were often seen as barriers to raising concerns, and the data, they write, suggest outsiders such as students are a source of challenge.
They did not attend the staff meetings and cannot verify whether these had any preventative effect. They argue that pre-existing workplace culture can be a countervailing force that suppresses openness and over time normalises deviance, so efforts at openness must take account of history, power, norms and hierarchy.
The paper does not name psychological safety. The bridge is ours: we read its informal peer challenge as voice routed around a formal channel staff consider risky, and its account of norms as showing managers' invitations to speak sitting inside a culture that can work against them.
Save this paper to a bibliography, keep notes on it, and export citations. Create a free account →
Related psychsafety.com articles (5)
- How We Respond
- Normalisation of Deviance (Challenger)
- Barriers to PS
- Whistleblowing & PS
- You Can't Fix a Secret
Related papers (4)
- Vaughan (1996): The Challenger Launch Decision: Risky Technology, Culture, and Deviance at NASA
- Dixon-Woods et al. (2014): Culture and behaviour in the English National Health Service: overview of lessons from a large multimethod study
- Martin et al. (2018): Making soft intelligence hard: a multi-site qualitative study of challenges relating to voice about safety concerns
- Older People's Commissioner for Wales (2012): Protection of Older People in Wales: Raising Concerns in the Workplace
