Psych Safety, by Iterum

When Power Makes Others Speechless: The Negative Impact of Leader Power on Team Performance

Tost, Gino & Larrick (2013) · Leader's felt power quietens teams

Tost, Gino & Larrick · Primary Research · Power & Equity, Voice & Silence, Team Learning · Academy of Management Journal · 2013 · Open access

Open this neighbourhood on the live map →

Tost, Gino and Larrick argue that a leader's subjective sense of power can spill over to harm team performance, and that whether it does depends on how the rest of the team responds. In their model, a formal leader who feels powerful talks more, members see the leader as less open and report less open communication, and performance falls; bootstrap tests supported this sequence in each study, though in Study 3 the interval ran to zero (-80.01 to 0.00). Verbal dominance needs others to yield the floor, and they propose that members grant this only to someone holding a formal position of authority.

Three experiments used tasks requiring members to share and integrate information, with power primed by having one person write about a time they had power over someone. In Study 1, 106 undergraduate and MBA students in 20 teams ran an Everest simulation in class. Members reported that high-power leaders talked for 32.7% of the time against 18.7% and rated them less open, and their teams reached 59.0% of their goals against 76.2%. Study 2 put 144 participants in 48 three-person teams solving a murder mystery, crossing the power prime with a nametag reading 'LEADER'. With a formal leader, 25.0% of high-power teams named the culprit against 75.0% of neutral-power teams; without one, the proportions were similar (54.5% and 61.5%). Primed individuals were rated more autocratic whether labelled leader or not, which they read as authority shaping how others react to dominance rather than whether it is attempted, though they call that effect 'fairly subtle'. In Study 3, 152 participants in 38 four-person teams chose among three CFO candidates. Without a reminder, no team with a high-power leader chose correctly, against 55.6% with a neutral-power leader; telling leaders that everyone had something unique to contribute 'essentially eliminated' the effects.

Some key interactions were only marginally significant, among them leader talking in Study 2 (p = .061) and performance in Study 3 (p = .08). They name as limits the laboratory and classroom settings, tasks needing information integration, and reliance on members' estimates of talking rather than recordings, and suggest a dominating leader may do less harm, or even help, in crises, under high uncertainty, or where the leader's expertise far exceeds the team's.

The paper does not use the term psychological safety, though it cites Edmondson, and one open communication item asks whether members 'held back in fear of what others thought'. We read it as experimental evidence for one route by which hierarchy can quieten a team: a leader's felt power, given room by a formal title.

Tost, L.P., Gino, F. and Larrick, R.P. (2013) 'When power makes others speechless: the negative impact of leader power on team performance', Academy of Management Journal, 56(5), pp. 1465-1486.

Save this paper to a bibliography, keep notes on it, and export citations. Create a free account →

Related psychsafety.com articles (5)

Related papers (7)

View the source paper →