Psych Safety, by Iterum

Tightening the Iron Cage: Concertive Control in Self-Managing Teams

Barker (1993) · Concertive control by peers

Barker · Case Study · Power & Equity, Culture & Context · Administrative Science Quarterly · 1993 · Paywalled

Open this neighbourhood on the live map →

James Barker's ethnography of ISE Communications, a small maker of telecommunications circuit boards that converted to self-managing teams in 1988, asks whether concertive control (Tompkins and Cheney's term), which workers achieve, Barker writes, by reaching 'a negotiated consensus on how to shape their behavior according to a set of core values', transcends the bureaucratic control it replaced. His analysis, he writes, suggests it does not free workers from Weber's iron cage of rational rules; at ISE it 'appeared to draw the iron cage tighter'.

The company employed about 150 people, some 90 in manufacturing. Barker visited mostly weekly from early 1990 to autumn 1992: 275 research hours, 37 in-depth interviews.

He traces three phases. First, teams turned the company's vision statement into a value consensus, as when a team agreed to work late to ship an order. Second, when many new workers were hired as temporaries, longer-tenured members turned that consensus into rules and enforced them with rewards and punishments: 'If you're a new person here, you're going to be watched.' One temporary said that, fearing for their jobs, temporaries 'tend to hold it in, what they want to say'. Third, the rules hardened: five minutes or more late counted as an 'occurrence', four in a month brought a written warning, and teams posted colour-coded attendance charts. To a person, older team workers told Barker they felt much more stress than under the old system. 'The team members had become their own masters and their own slaves.'

Barker gives two reasons for the added force: workers enforce on each other rules they made themselves, and the control is less apparent, members being relatively unaware of how their own system controls them. Agreement with other research on self-management, he writes, suggests concertive control 'is more powerful and has a greater ability to control than the bureaucratic system it replaces'; to resist, workers 'must be willing to risk their human dignity'. He grants that much of the pressure to formalise came from the need to survive in a competitive market, that the tensions between full-time and temporary workers were not enduring, and that the point at which an idea becomes a norm and then a rule is 'very indistinct'. On the other hand, he writes, the locus of authority had transferred from the hierarchy to the teams' values, norms and rules, and the disciplines 'appeared to work'; during the third phase ISE became profitable again.

The paper does not mention psychological safety. The bridge is ours: at ISE, removing the supervisor did not remove the interpersonal cost of stepping out of line, but moved it to peers, in a system of control harder for those inside it to see. Barker studied control, not voice; what went unsaid rests on one worker's account.

Barker, J.R. (1993) 'Tightening the iron cage: concertive control in self-managing teams', Administrative Science Quarterly, 38(3), pp. 408–437.

Save this paper to a bibliography, keep notes on it, and export citations. Create a free account →

Related psychsafety.com articles (3)

Related papers (6)

View the source paper →