The Field Guide › Paper
A review of the growing phenomenon of criminal prosecution following professional mistakes in aviation and healthcare. Dekker examines the social causes — rising risk consciousness, intolerance of failure, and media pressure — and the organizational and psychological consequences. The key finding: criminalisation directly threatens safety by suppressing voluntary error reporting, the mechanism through which safety cultures learn. Workers and professionals who fear prosecution do not disclose near-misses; investigations are impeded; and the individuals prosecuted suffer severe secondary psychological harm. The paper provides the empirical and theoretical grounding for why accountability without psychological safety is not just ineffective but actively dangerous — and why just culture frameworks must go beyond simply removing blame to actively protecting those who report honestly.