Psych Safety, by Iterum

Psychological Safety During the Test of New Work Processes in an Emergency Department

Dieckmann et al (2022) · Physical space frames the model

Dieckmann et al · Primary Research · Team Learning, Culture & Context, Safety & Error · BMC Health Services Research · 2022 · Open access

Open this neighbourhood on the live map →

Dieckmann, Tulloch, Dalgaard and Varming take a model of team psychological safety, drawn in their first figure as 'inspired by' Edmondson (1999), into a Danish emergency department testing new work processes, and ask whether its antecedents and consequences fully describe how staff perceived psychological safety, and whether all are needed. Although 'limited in scale', they conclude, it supports the model for many of the dynamics staff experienced, though not all.

The change was an 'infection pathway' at Herlev and Gentofte Hospital: from 18 February to 3 March 2019 the day's infection team worked from a dedicated four-bed room. Two nurses and three physicians were interviewed before and after the test, and three more staff afterwards only. Paraphrased interview notes were coded against the model's five antecedents and five consequences, the remainder inductively. Seven of eight invited team members completed a Danish version of Edmondson's seven-item questionnaire, analysed with descriptive statistics only, and a four-hour workshop in September 2019 drew seven leaders and two administrative staff, without the test's clinicians.

Interview material populated every antecedent and consequence. The mean total was 39.8 of 49, which they call 'very good'; their stated threshold for high levels is above 40. They suggest that, when applied to improvement work, it may be appropriate to change the model in three ways: the physical environment as a background to every element, after staff described a room too small, windowless and far from materials; perceived treatment quality as an added antecedent, since participants' perceived psychological safety fell where they saw their patients' care at risk; and bidirectional arrows, because, in this context at least, they believe witnessing learning behaviour confirmed psychological safety, and its absence could undermine it.

They call the study exploratory and write that the small sample does not warrant revising a well-established model on these findings alone, so they add theoretical argument. They also name notes in place of full transcripts, a suspected translation problem with the item on taking risks, supportive leaders who may have positively influenced the findings, and uncertain reach beyond emergency departments.

Psychological safety is the subject throughout, defined after Edmondson as the degree to which people perceive their work environment as supportive of interpersonally risky behaviours. Its step is to set the whole model within the physical environment, and to add staff judgement of whether patients are well cared for as an antecedent of team psychological safety.

Dieckmann, P., Tulloch, S., Dalgaard, A.E. and Varming, K. (2022) 'Psychological safety during the test of new work processes in an emergency department', BMC Health Services Research, 22(1), Article 307.

Save this paper to a bibliography, keep notes on it, and export citations. Create a free account →

Related psychsafety.com articles (5)

Related papers (9)

View the source paper →