Psych Safety, by Iterum

Stuttering and Labor Market Outcomes in the United States

Gerlach et al (2018) · Stuttering's earnings gap, by gender

Gerlach et al · Primary Research · Power & Equity, Voice & Silence · Journal of Speech, Language, and Hearing Research · 2018 · Open access

Open this neighbourhood on the live map →

A secondary analysis of a US national cohort which finds that adults who reported stuttering earned significantly less than their fluent peers, and that the sources of the gap differed by gender: for men most of the gap matched differences in observable characteristics, for women most of it did not. Gerlach, Totty, Subramanian and Zebrowski used the National Longitudinal Study of Adolescent to Adult Health (Add Health), counting as people who stutter only the 261, of some 13,600 respondents, who answered yes to a stuttering question at both Wave 3 and Wave 4, the second at ages 24 to 32; about 84 per cent called their stuttering mild. They analysed men and women separately, with school fixed effects, using regression, propensity score matching and Blinder-Oaxaca decomposition.

With controls for demographics and comorbidity, regression put the annual earnings gap at $7,628 for men and $7,154 for women (p < .05); matching gave larger estimates, $10,766 and $18,712, though the earnings estimates rest on 71 men and 30 women who stutter in the regressions and 67 and 27 in the matching. By regression, men who stutter were 8.1 per cent less likely to be in the labour force; by matching, women who stutter were 23.2 per cent more likely to be underemployed. Neither controlled method found a significant difference in employment or receipt of public assistance. In the decomposition, 89 per cent of the men's unadjusted $10,213 gap was explained, chiefly by occupation, a proxy for self-stigma, background and education; for women, 64 per cent of a $12,678 gap was unexplained (p < .01). Unexplained gaps are often read as employer discrimination but also absorb unobserved differences, and Gerlach and colleagues conclude that preliminary evidence indicates discrimination 'may have contributed', particularly for women.

Their stated limits: stuttering was self-reported, so the group may include fluent speakers, and with 84 per cent calling it mild the results likely best represent mild disfluency; the self-stigma proxy, five personality items, cannot be claimed to reflect stuttering-related self-stigma specifically; unobserved heterogeneity calls for caution before reading the association as causal; and the data hold no information on employer characteristics. The paper does not mention psychological safety; the bridge is ours. On the personality items used as that proxy, people who stutter were more likely to agree that 'I keep in the background' and 'I don't talk a lot', and Gerlach and colleagues call for research on employer-employee dynamics such as employers' familiarity with people who stutter. We read the gap as one estimate of what speaking differently may cost at work, a cost these figures suggest falls unevenly by gender.

Gerlach, H., Totty, E., Subramanian, A. and Zebrowski, P. (2018) 'Stuttering and labor market outcomes in the United States', Journal of Speech, Language, and Hearing Research, 61(7), pp. 1649-1663.

Save this paper to a bibliography, keep notes on it, and export citations. Create a free account →

Related psychsafety.com articles (3)

Related papers (2)

View the source paper →