Psych Safety, by Iterum

A New Model of Work Role Performance: Positive Behavior in Uncertain and Interdependent Contexts

Griffin, Neal & Parker (2007) · Proficiency, adaptivity, proactivity

Griffin, Neal & Parker · Primary Research · Measurement & Method · Academy of Management Journal · 2007 · Paywalled

Open this neighbourhood on the live map →

Griffin, Neal and Parker argue that two features of context shape which behaviours an organisation values, and build a model of work role performance on them. Uncertainty sets how far a role can be formalised, giving three forms of behaviour: 'proficiency' (meeting requirements that can be formalised), 'adaptivity' (adapting to changes in a work system or roles) and 'proactivity' ('self-directed action to anticipate or initiate change'). Interdependence sets how far a role is embedded in a wider social system, so each form can be directed at the individual task, the team or the organisation, giving nine subdimensions. The forms are not mutually exclusive; what varies with context is their relative importance.

The test used 27 items, three per subdimension, some adapted from citizenship and extra-role measures. In Australia, 491 supervisors from 32 state government agencies rated subordinates, and employees of two public sector organisations rated themselves (final samples 1,228 and 927). They concluded that a nine-factor structure was the most appropriate representation in all three samples, although correlations among subdimensions tended to be higher for supervisors. In the employee samples, role clarity had its strongest path to individual task proficiency, openness to change was more strongly related to adaptivity, role breadth self-efficacy to proactivity and affective organisational commitment to organisation member behaviours. Team support was more strongly related to team member than to individual task behaviours in both organisations, but than to organisation member behaviours in only one. In one organisation, expert ratings of 22 work units correlated with aggregated self-reports of team member (r = .37) and organisation member proactivity (r = .48), but not significantly with individual task proactivity; suggestion rates in 24 units correlated with individual task and team member proactivity (both r = .36) but not significantly with organisation member proactivity (r = -.12).

They name the limits: some results rest on self-reports; the supervisors' higher correlations 'raise some concern' about how clearly observers distinguish the subdimensions; the small number of items might 'mask a finer-grained dimensional structure'; and the external evidence covers proactive behaviours only.

The paper does not mention psychological safety. It does call proactive behaviours 'more risky' than adaptive ones, citing Morrison and Phelps (1999) on people weighing whether the risks of taking charge outweigh the benefits. The bridge is ours: we read one of its team member proactivity items, 'Suggested ways to make your work unit more effective', as close to voice. It offers no evidence on interpersonal risk.

Griffin, M.A., Neal, A. and Parker, S.K. (2007) 'A new model of work role performance: Positive behavior in uncertain and interdependent contexts', Academy of Management Journal, 50(2), pp. 327–347.

Save this paper to a bibliography, keep notes on it, and export citations. Create a free account →

Related psychsafety.com articles (2)

Related papers (3)

View the source paper →