Psych Safety, by Iterum

Communication as Group Process Mediator of Aircrew Performance

Kanki & Foushee (1989) · Familiarity reshapes cockpit talk

Kanki & Foushee · Primary Research · Safety & Error, Voice & Silence, Team Learning · Aviation, Space, and Environmental Medicine · 1989 · Paywalled

Open this neighbourhood on the live map →

Crews who had just spent several days flying together talked differently in a simulated flight from crews who had not, and the difference ran towards the task. Kanki and Foushee went back to a NASA Ames full-mission simulator study of fatigue. Taking crews straight from a duty cycle had meant most of them had just worked together for several days, and, unexpectedly, crews that had worked together recently performed better, overriding the presumed effect of fatigue. Using McGrath's input, process and output framework, they asked whether communication might be the process that mediates that effect.

Nineteen two-pilot airline crews, 10 that had flown together and 9 that had not, flew the same scenario: deteriorating weather, a forced missed approach, then a hydraulic failure and a diversion whose only reasonable airport had a relatively short, wet runway. The captain was pilot flying throughout. Transcribed statements were coded into a 19-category scheme from a typology by Foushee and Manos built on Bales' Interaction Process Analysis, and each category was tested for familiarity by role. In the earlier data, familiar crews averaged 5.0 errors per flight against 11.67 (p < 0.009), the gap widening as error severity rose.

Familiar crews produced more acknowledgements (p < 0.01) and, more weakly, more statements of intent and more communication overall (both p < 0.07), which Kanki and Foushee read as greater exchange and validation of task information. Their first officers gave more answers (p < 0.08) and disagreed more (p < 0.005). Unfamiliar crews produced more non-task talk (p < 0.025) and more laughter and jokes (p < 0.05), read as getting acquainted, possibly a natural stage of team development. Captains' and first officers' non-task talk correlated at r = 0.95 across crews, which they explain as matching: one pilot cannot keep non-task talk going unless the other joins in.

The link to performance is implied but, as the paper says, not directly examined. The paper notes the small number of crews, offset by 221 to 497 speech acts per pilot. Two further limits are ours to add: familiarity came from a fatigue manipulation, so the crews who had flown together were nearly all from its high-fatigue condition, and nineteen categories were tested separately, with three of the seven familiarity effects short of p < 0.05. Kanki and Foushee add that first officers' contributions are intricately bound up in the captain's actions.

The paper does not use the term psychological safety, and the bridge is ours. They set first officers' extra disagreement against subordinates' reported hesitancy to question pilots-in-command; we read it as a behavioural trace of lower interpersonal risk that came with shared history, though the study counted speech, not climate.

Kanki, B.G. and Foushee, H.C. (1989) 'Communication as group process mediator of aircrew performance', Aviation, Space, and Environmental Medicine, 60(5), pp. 402–410.

Save this paper to a bibliography, keep notes on it, and export citations. Create a free account →

Related psychsafety.com articles (4)

Related papers (6)

View the source paper →