Breaking the Silence: The Moderating Effects of Self-Monitoring in Predicting Speaking Up in the Workplace
Premeaux & Bedeian (2003) · Opposite slopes by self-monitoring
A field study of whether self-monitoring, the extent to which people observe, regulate and control the public appearances of self they display, changes how individual and contextual factors relate to speaking up. Sonya Fontenot Premeaux and Arthur Bedeian define speaking up as openly stating one's views or opinions about workplace matters, and keep it apart from voice, which they argue has no universally accepted definition. Their result runs in opposite directions: in regression lines plotted one standard deviation above and below the self-monitoring mean, low self-monitors spoke up more as internal locus of control, self-esteem, top-management openness and trust in supervisor increased, while for high self-monitors each line sloped downward; the separate slopes were not tested.
The sample was 118 employees of a southern United States telecommunications company, from 291 surveyed, each rated on speaking up by one to three coworkers, mostly peers and 15 per cent supervisors. Speaking up was measured on a scale they developed in three phases, used with five items (alpha 0.87) after dropping a reverse-scored item many respondents misread. Employees reported the predictors themselves, including Ashford and colleagues' top-management openness measure and a six-item trust in supervisor measure adapted from various sources.
No predictor correlated significantly with speaking up on its own, and none explained more than 1 per cent of its variance alone. Each interaction with self-monitoring was significant, reported as p < 0.05, with Table III giving p values from 0.02 to 0.05, two of them at 0.05, and each added 3 to 4 per cent of variance. For the openness result, they suggest that where speaking up is commonplace it may offer high self-monitors little as a way to cultivate a unique public image; they call the reason for the negative locus of control slope among high self-monitors speculative.
Their stated limits: a cross-sectional design that cannot rule out reverse causality; one organisation and a highly educated sample; no self-assessments, which they suggest could help investigate the supposition, basic to their scheme, that the two groups speak up for different motives; and a sample size that led them to run four separate regressions rather than one omnibus test, accepting more risk of Type I error, so that the significance of the findings should be judged accordingly.
The paper does not use the term psychological safety, though it opens on employees' belief that speaking up is 'a risky proposition' that may bring retaliation. The bridge is ours: we read top-management openness and trust in supervisor as close to the conditions psychological safety describes, and the finding as a caution, in this one sample, that higher perceived openness and trust went with more speaking up from low self-monitors and less from high self-monitors.
Save this paper to a bibliography, keep notes on it, and export citations. Create a free account →
Related psychsafety.com articles (5)
Related papers (6)
- Hirschman (1970): Exit, Voice, and Loyalty: Responses to Decline in Firms, Organizations, and States
- McAllister (1995): Affect- and Cognition-Based Trust as Foundations for Interpersonal Cooperation in Organizations
- Van Dyne & LePine (1998): Helping and Voice Extra-Role Behaviors: Evidence of Construct and Predictive Validity
- Morrison & Milliken (2000): Organizational Silence: A Barrier to Change and Development in a Pluralistic World
- Morrison (2011): Employee Voice Behavior: Integration and Directions for Future Research
- Ashford et al (1998): Out on a Limb: The Role of Context and Impression Management in Selling Gender-Equity Issues
