Psych Safety, by Iterum

Employee Voice Behavior: Integration and Directions for Future Research

Morrison (2011) · Two judgements, three voice types

Morrison · Review & Meta-analysis · Voice & Silence · Academy of Management Annals · 2011 · Paywalled

Open this neighbourhood on the live map →

Morrison's Annals review sets out to define voice clearly and to integrate a literature she calls somewhat fragmented, with no overarching framework yet for how the factors that foster or inhibit voice relate. Her integrated conceptualisation is 'discretionary communication of ideas, suggestions, concerns, or opinions about work-related issues with the intent to improve organizational or unit functioning', covering voice to one's boss and to one's teammates alike. She distinguishes voice from upward communication, whistle-blowing and issue selling while drawing on them, excludes other uses of the word (among them the exit, voice, loyalty and neglect, industrial relations and justice senses), and argues that voice and silence are opposites on a single continuum rather than separate constructs.

At the centre is a model of the voice process. The literature, she writes, presumes that the driving motive for voice is a desire to help the organisation or work unit, and emphasises two judgements: the perceived efficacy of voice (whether speaking up is likely to be effective) and the perceived safety of voice (its risks or potential negative outcomes). These may strengthen or attenuate the link between that motive and actual voice, and contextual factors (among them structure, culture, supervisor openness and leadership style) and individual factors (among them job attitudes, personality, tenure and status) both operate by affecting them. Citing Kish-Gephart and colleagues, Detert and Edmondson, and Morrison and Rothman, she adds that fear can in some cases short-circuit deliberation, so failure to voice may in some situations reflect more of an automatic fear-based response.

The review is narrative and states no limits of its own; those it names are the field's. Outside whistle-blowing she finds the evidence on what voice does for the speaker mixed, yet reads it as suggesting voice often has positive implications for the actor, so the implicit beliefs many employees hold about its dangers may often be unfounded. Her agenda covers three message types (suggestion-focused, problem-focused and opinion-focused voice), with self-protective concerns perhaps less prominent for suggestions; tactics and choice of target; a caution that voice will not always benefit the collective and that there may be too much of it; voice climate and emotion; and better methods, since most studies take a single perspective and are cross-sectional.

Psychological safety enters only in reporting other studies: surgeons downplaying power differences enhanced it (Edmondson, 2003), and perceived manager openness fostered voice through it (Detert and Burris, 2007). The term she uses for the second judgement is the perceived safety of voice, and she neither defines psychological safety nor equates the two. We read that judgement as the speaker's own reading of psychological safety, with efficacy beside it as a reminder that feeling safe is not all that decides whether people speak.

Morrison, E.W. (2011) 'Employee voice behavior: Integration and directions for future research', Academy of Management Annals, 5(1), pp. 373–412.

The Foam Strike, a Learning Lab session on the loss of Space Shuttle Columbia (2003), draws on this paper: run it with your team. Open the Learning Lab →

Save this paper to a bibliography, keep notes on it, and export citations. Create a free account →

Related psychsafety.com articles (4)

Related papers (37)

View the source paper →