Reading the Wind: How Middle Managers Assess the Context for Selling Issues to Top Managers
Dutton et al (1997) · Safety cues, selling recipe
Two exploratory studies at one Midwestern telecommunications company of what middle managers weigh before deciding whether to sell a strategic issue to top management, a choice Jane Dutton, Susan Ashford, Regina O'Neill, Erika Hayes and Elizabeth Wierba say Dutton and Ashford's 1993 framework attended to less than how to sell. Study 1 reads the cues for a favourable or unfavourable context; Study 2 the factors in image risk.
Study 1 interviewed 30 middle managers drawn at random from 187, in autumn 1992, as the CEO announced a 7 per cent cut in management staff, with 92 per cent agreement between two coders. Top management's willingness to listen (18 mentions) and a supportive culture (13) led the favourable cues, ahead of competitive and economic pressures (11) and organisational change (10). Fear of negative consequences (10), downsizing (9), uncertainty (9) and a conservative culture (8) marked the context unfavourable. They found it surprising that the word 'fear' was used so often, and that no one mentioned trying to change the context itself. Since three of the four favourable themes noted a change in conditions, they suggest change may matter as much as absolute levels.
Study 2 mailed all 187 a survey (118 replies, 63 per cent) rating 30 conditions on a 7-point scale for image-loss risk; a factor analysis gave four factors, three interpretable. 'Norm Violation' (a boss who has turned the issue down, no data, no solution) was rated riskiest (mean 6.1), above 'Political Vulnerability' (past failure, an issue implying criticism of upper management or change, selling alone; 5.4) and a distant relationship with top management (4.9), the three means all significantly different. Norm Violation broke a recipe everyone in 10 pretest interviews echoed: push the issue with your boss first, back appeals with data, and it helps to bundle it with a solution.
They argue such recipes can later constrain selling, leaving managers unlikely to raise emerging issues with few facts or solutions, and that if middle managers self-censor on criticism or change, much of the adaptive value of selling is lost. Their stated limits: one old, bureaucratic organisation, open-ended questions and new scales.
The paper names psychological safety, without citing a source for the term. A favourable context, they write, 'offers both psychological safety to the potential issue seller, as well as windows of opportunity', and they propose for future study that 'people sell issues more often when they have a sense of psychological safety', particularly around their image. It does not measure the construct, though its own gloss on that mechanism (an issue that is no criticism of top management, sold with others and with supporting data) echoes Study 2's items; we read those factors as one firm's itemised view of the interpersonal risk the term points at.
The Foam Strike, a Learning Lab session on the loss of Space Shuttle Columbia (2003), draws on this paper: run it with your team. Open the Learning Lab →
Save this paper to a bibliography, keep notes on it, and export citations. Create a free account →
Related psychsafety.com articles (5)
- Calculus of Voice
- Building PS Upwards
- Don't Bring Me Problems
- Job Security & PS
- Redundancy, Layoffs & PS
Related papers (11)
- Morrison (2014): Employee Voice and Silence
- Milliken et al (2003): An Exploratory Study of Employee Silence: Issues That Employees Don't Communicate Upward and Why
- Detert & Burris (2007): Leadership Behavior and Employee Voice: Is the Door Really Open?
- Kahneman & Tversky (1979): Prospect Theory: An Analysis of Decision under Risk
- Kish-Gephart, Detert, Treviño & Edmondson (2009): Silenced by Fear: The Nature, Sources, and Consequences of Fear at Work
- Detert & Treviño (2010): Speaking Up to Higher-Ups: How Supervisors and Skip-Level Leaders Influence Employee Voice
- Morrison (2011): Employee Voice Behavior: Integration and Directions for Future Research
- Detert & Edmondson (2011): Implicit Voice Theories: Taken-for-Granted Rules of Self-Censorship at Work
- Liang, Farh & Farh (2012): Psychological Antecedents of Promotive and Prohibitive Voice: A Two-Wave Examination
- Coutifaris & Grant (2021): Taking Your Team Behind the Curtain: The Effects of Leader Feedback-Sharing and Feedback-Seeking on Team Psychological Safety
- Dutton & Ashford (1993): Selling Issues to Top Management
