The Voice Cultivation Process: How Team Members Can Help Upward Voice Live on to Implementation
Satterstrom, Kerrissey & DiBenigno (2021) · Allies revive rejected ideas
Satterstrom, Kerrissey and DiBenigno move the study of upward voice from the moment of speaking to the idea's later life, and from the voicer and authority holder to the team that heard it. In a 31-month ethnography of one multidisciplinary team at an outpatient primary care clinic in the north-eastern United States, 49 ideas from lower-power members that appeared to fail when voiced reached implementation, kept alive, mostly by other members and on one pathway mainly by the voicer, through what they call the voice cultivation process.
Satterstrom observed 78 of the team's 89 weekly meetings from September 2012 to June 2014 and interviewed every member. Doctors, faculty and managers, who held authority to implement ideas, matched nurses, medical assistants, receptionists and patients in number. Of 208 ideas voiced upward by lower-power members, 34% got past initial rejection and 24% were implemented, while 78% of higher-power members' ideas were accepted when first proposed.
Every implemented idea followed one of five pathways, linked to why it was resisted: allyship, where others doubted its feasibility or importance (14 ideas); persistence by the voicer, where others did not understand other roles' work or were unaware of the problem (10); co-crafting, where higher-power members would give up core work (7); 'problematizing', where they would take on more core work (7); and 'catalyzing', where a shock, in all but one case a member leaving or joining, revived an idea abandoned after earlier resistance (11). Promotive framing alone did not, they suggest, fully explain which ideas endured, and in matched comparisons, the predominant reason failed ideas, many viable elsewhere, were not revived was that members did not use commensurate combinations of the practices suited to why they were resisted. On every pathway lower-power members, voicers included, enacted more of the cultivation practices than higher-power members did (53% to 60%, with those involving three or more people coded to the team separately), and originators did not always keep the credit, which they say raises ethical questions about advising lower-power members to speak up.
Their stated limits are one purposively chosen team, so the theory needs testing elsewhere, and observation confined to meetings, though interviews and shadowing suggested outside conversations were not a major issue.
They describe the team as an ideal case partly because it 'explicitly valued leader inclusivity and psychological safety', and all members took training on it, yet it was 'predominately characterized by moments of failed upward voice' by lower-power members. The study does not measure it, and leaves how climates 'such as the level of psychological safety' affect implementation to future research. We read its finding that the capacity to bring ideas to implementation 'does not reside with' leaders alone as pointing to peers as well as leaders in what becomes of voice.
Save this paper to a bibliography, keep notes on it, and export citations. Create a free account →
Related psychsafety.com articles (5)
- How We Respond
- Collective Responsibility
- Psychological Safety in Healthcare
- Reducing Power Gradients
- Psychologically Safe Meetings
Related papers (18)
- Edmondson (1999): Psychological Safety and Learning Behavior in Work Teams
- Morrison (2014): Employee Voice and Silence
- Hirschman (1970): Exit, Voice, and Loyalty: Responses to Decline in Firms, Organizations, and States
- Milliken et al (2003): An Exploratory Study of Employee Silence: Issues That Employees Don't Communicate Upward and Why
- Detert & Burris (2007): Leadership Behavior and Employee Voice: Is the Door Really Open?
- Morrison & Milliken (2000): Organizational Silence: A Barrier to Change and Development in a Pluralistic World
- Magee & Galinsky (2008): Social Hierarchy: The Self-Reinforcing Nature of Power and Status
- Ashford et al (2009): Speaking Up and Speaking Out: The Leadership Dynamics of Voice in Organizations
- Edmondson (2003): Speaking Up in the Operating Room: How Team Leaders Promote Learning in Interdisciplinary Action Teams
- McClean et al (2018): The Social Consequences of Voice: An Examination of Voice Type and Gender on Status and Subsequent Leader Emergence
- Morrison (2011): Employee Voice Behavior: Integration and Directions for Future Research
- Detert & Edmondson (2011): Implicit Voice Theories: Taken-for-Granted Rules of Self-Censorship at Work
- Nembhard & Edmondson (2006): Making it Safe: The Effects of Leader Inclusiveness and Professional Status on Psychological Safety and Improvement Efforts in Health Care Teams
- Kerrissey et al. (2024): Overcoming Walls and Voids: Responsive Practices That Enable Frontline Workers to Feel Heard
- Liang, Farh & Farh (2012): Psychological Antecedents of Promotive and Prohibitive Voice: A Two-Wave Examination
- Detert, Burris, Harrison & Martin (2013): Voice Flows to and around Leaders: Understanding When Units Are Helped or Hurt by Employee Voice
- Kerrissey, Satterstrom & Edmondson (2020): Into the Fray: Adaptive Approaches to Studying Novel Teamwork Forms
- Dutton & Ashford (1993): Selling Issues to Top Management
