Psych Safety, by Iterum

Who Gets Credit for Input? Demographic and Structural Status Cues in Voice Recognition

Howell et al (2015) · Same voice, unequal credit

Howell et al · Primary Research · Voice & Silence, Power & Equity · Journal of Applied Psychology · 2015 · Open access

Open this neighbourhood on the live map →

Taeya Howell, David Harrison, Ethan Burris and James Detert separate two things voice research often treats as one: how much employees say they speak up, and how much their supervisor credits them for it. Their finding is that the same reported voice earns different credit depending on who offers it. The panel study covers 693 employees in 89 branch and headquarters units of two US credit unions, rated by 118 supervisors. Voice expression came from employees' own reports, status cues from HR records and peer network nominations, and voice recognition from a three-item supervisor rating of how often an employee raised problems and ideas and the overall value of their input. Supervisors rated performance about a year later (n = 587).

With reported voice held constant, supervisors gave more recognition to White employees (B = 0.18), full-time staff (B = 0.32), incumbents rather than first-year newcomers (B = 0.20) and, most strongly, employees central in their unit's advice network (B = 0.81). Friendship centrality made no significant difference. Gender ran against the hypothesis: men, under 16% of front-line staff and 30% of supervisors here, were credited less (B = -0.19), which they suggest may mean women simply have higher status in this context.

Whether speaking up more helps was mixed. Voice raised recognition for incumbents but not for newcomers; interactions with ethnicity (positive) and gender (negative) were significant, though neither group's slope differed from zero, and the ethnicity and newcomer interactions lost significance when all interactions were entered together, while gender's held; and voice from the edge of the friendship network was credited more, the reverse of the prediction. Their summary is that more voice in general 'does not help those with lower ascribed or assigned status'. Recognition then predicted performance ratings a year later and fully carried the effect of reported voice on them; five of six status cues reached performance through it, and demographic differences in that credit, they say, 'can serve as an implicit pathway for discrimination'.

They state the limits: mediation rests on two time points, with voice expression and recognition measured together; some confounds are addressable only in experiments; and status may also shape how much employees report speaking up. Supplementary data from two further credit unions showed voice predicting later recognition, not the reverse.

The paper does not name psychological safety. The bridge is ours: psychological safety asks whether people believe speaking up is safe, and this paper looks at the receiving end. We read it as a reason that doubts about whether voice is worth it may be accurate for lower-status employees: here the same reported voice earned them less credit.

Howell, T.M., Harrison, D.A., Burris, E.R. and Detert, J.R. (2015) 'Who gets credit for input? Demographic and structural status cues in voice recognition', Journal of Applied Psychology, 100(6), pp. 1765–1784.

Save this paper to a bibliography, keep notes on it, and export citations. Create a free account →

Related psychsafety.com articles (5)

Related papers (11)

View the source paper →