Psych Safety, by Iterum

‘Fitting in’ or ‘Standing Out’: Working-Class Students in UK Higher Education

Reay, Crozier & Clayton (2010) · Institutional habitus and learner identity

Reay, Crozier & Clayton · Primary Research · Power & Equity, Culture & Context · British Educational Research Journal · 2010 · Open access

Open this neighbourhood on the live map →

Reay, Crozier and Clayton follow 27 working-class students across four UK higher education institutions and argue that institutional habitus, which in their account includes a university's academic status, curriculum offer, organisational practices and 'expressive order', shapes how those students come to see themselves as learners. At Eastern and Northern, they conclude, fitting in can be problematic, especially if it means academic complacency and a lack of challenge.

The ESRC study defined class by the ONS categories L7 to L14. A questionnaire to first- and second-year students yielded 1,209 responses. The case-study students were followed from April of one year to June of the next through 97 face-to-face interviews and observation of lectures and seminars, at an elite university (Southern), a civic one (Midland), a post-1992 one (Northern) and a further education college (Eastern).

At Eastern and Northern, they write, congruence between individual and institutional habitus often lulls students into a sense of security, providing a comfort zone where they feel accepted, but there are costs. There, where paid work and family compete with study, learner identities remain relatively fragile and unconfident. In the survey 64% of Northern students did paid work against 8% at Southern. Kylie, a Northern history student, says she claims not to have done work she has done, 'just to sort of fit in', and says 'Socially, yeah, I fit in totally here, I just don't fit in academically'. This self-doubt was gendered, they write, citing Leathwood and Read (2008): women more than men felt they did not really deserve to be in higher education. At Southern, and to a lesser extent Midland, students developed a strong sense of themselves as academic learners, and, particularly at Southern, class background became relatively unimportant in learning contexts, though it resurfaced in social ones. The crucial difference, they add, lies more in the learner identities students bring, and learners cannot be mapped neatly onto institutions.

They conclude that students managing a productive tension between fitting in and standing out deal most successfully with the challenges, though working-class entrants to elite universities face considerable identity work, and that the success of the very few has little impact on continuing classed and racialised inequalities. The paper does not set out its own limits.

The paper does not name psychological safety; the bridge is ours. We read Kylie's playing down of her effort as concealment for the sake of fit, and the study as a caution that a group where people feel accepted can still make it costly to stand out. Its subject is students, not workplaces.

Reay, D., Crozier, G. and Clayton, J. (2010) '‘Fitting in’ or ‘standing out’: Working-class students in UK higher education', British Educational Research Journal, 36(1), pp. 107–124.

Save this paper to a bibliography, keep notes on it, and export citations. Create a free account →

Related psychsafety.com articles (4)

Related papers (5)

View the source paper →