Belonging as Situated Practice
Gravett & Ajjawi (2022) · Belonging across timespaces
Gravett and Ajjawi offer a conceptual rethinking of student belonging in higher education. They argue that the dominant account treats belonging as a universally positive, uniform experience and a fixed state a student achieves, and propose instead that it is 'situated, relational and processual', a 'sociomaterial practice that shifts within, across and beyond online and face to face timespaces'. They treat the COVID-19 move to emergency remote teaching as an opening, in which belonging, they suggest, can no longer be taken for granted as located within fixed times and spaces.
The paper reports no data of its own; it works through theory and earlier studies. They draw on Massey on space, Braidotti's 'process-ontology' and Adam's timescapes, time and space intertwined. They name three omissions. Belonging is often assumed to be universal rather than classed, racialised and gendered, though student bodies have diversified, and they read belonging as a normative category, 'potentially exclusionary and even harmful'. Dominant discourses also often fail to consider students who may actively choose not to belong: they cite Guyotte and colleagues, for whom 'belongingness is not inherently positive', and Mann's point that for some students belonging suggests a requirement to 'homogenise one's identity'. And prevalent discussions frame belonging in humanist, individualised terms that leave out space, place, time and non-human actors.
Online learning, they note, has been sold as anywhere, anytime, yet the student must be somewhere and access must occur in time. Carving study space out of beds and dining tables might cut along equity lines; access, they argue, is 'a necessary first step to belonging'. Remote study might also reduce travel time or alleviate social anxiety for some, and belonging and un-belonging might coexist. They anticipate the objection that this dilutes the term, and say their critique is not aimed at discarding it. Belonging, they write, 'is not merely a pathway to retention'; a situated, relational lens, they add, encourages educators to avoid generalised assumptions and to engage in regular dialogue with students. The paper does not set out its own limits.
The paper does not name psychological safety; the bridge is ours. It does cite Yuval-Davis's definition of belonging, which includes feeling safe. We read it as a caution against treating belonging, or safety, as a fixed, uniform state that people have or lack: on their account a student may belong at some times and places and not others. Its subject is students, not workplaces.
Save this paper to a bibliography, keep notes on it, and export citations. Create a free account →
