‘Student Engagement’ and the Tyranny of Participation
Gourlay (2015) · Quiet study read as passivity
Gourlay argues that 'student engagement', the guiding concept behind national student surveys in the USA, the UK and Australasia, is, as Kahn (2013) points out, weakly theorised, and ideologically loaded, its 'legitimate' forms united by a focus on activity that is 'communicative, recordable, public, observable and often communal'. Its reification of participation, she argues, may look student-centred while underscoring 'restrictive, culturally specific and normative notions' of acceptable practice, so that practices which are 'quiet, private, non-verbal and non-observable' risk being bracketed as 'essentially deviant and in need of remediation'. The result, she suggests it could be argued, approaches a 'tyranny of participation'.
She notes that in Coates's four engagement styles only 'passive' is cast negatively, and that the styles, though proposed as transient states, are applied to the individual, not practice. From development studies she takes Kothari's challenge to the 'orthodoxy of participation', in a volume titled Participation: The New Tyranny?: a seemingly empowering concept may coerce people into subject positions serving the ideologies of the more powerful. The orthodoxy, she suggests, might be read as underscoring a Western, post-enlightenment fantasy of the 'ideal' student, and the risk may relate to the pathologisation of 'passive' East Asian classroom behaviour.
Her alternative is sociomaterial, drawing on Actor-Network Theory: engagement sits in networks that include non-human actors such as 'mobile devices, pens, computers, books, electricity'. The illustration is from a study reported elsewhere (Gourlay and Oliver 2013): students were given iPod touch devices and asked to document their practices over a one-year period, with a series of interviews; no sample size is given here. In one student's diagram of writing an essay, most steps appear, she writes, to have been 'textual, private, not normally amenable to direct observation'. She calls this 'one snapshot' that 'cannot be used as the basis of strong empirical claims', though the project's findings were, she reports, consistent with her analysis. Conceding that complete disengagement is clearly problematic, she asks that policy rest on fine-grained qualitative understanding of student practices, especially those that are 'hidden, textual and private'.
The paper does not name psychological safety; the bridge is ours. We read it as a caution against taking visible, verbal participation as the sign of a safe group, since a norm that equates quiet with disengagement may mark as deficient the practices it cannot see. Her evidence concerns university students, not workplaces.
Save this paper to a bibliography, keep notes on it, and export citations. Create a free account →
Related psychsafety.com articles (5)
- Body Language & Non-Verbal Communication
- Not Same for Everyone
- Power of Silence
- Types of Silence
- Verbally Speaking Up
