Language, Discipline and ‘Teaching Like a Champion’
Cushing (2021) · Scripted classrooms as language policy
Cushing argues that in schools in England the policing of how pupils speak is bound up with the policing of how they behave and move, and that Doug Lemov's Teach Like a Champion (TLAC) works as 'a de facto language policy for teachers'. Policy already pairs them: the Teachers' Standards require teachers to 'manage behaviour' and to promote 'the correct use of standard English'. Extending Clark's 'disciplining of English' and Cameron's 'verbal hygiene', he argues that teachers are 'positioned as language policy managers who work within a system of surveillance, compliance, coercion and control'.
The fieldwork was ethnographic-orientated: termly visits over one academic year to New Urban Academy (NUA, a pseudonym), a large academy in outer London serving a principally white, working-class community, proudly zero-tolerance, built around TLAC, with video cameras in every classroom. He read policy texts and TLAC materials through critical discourse analysis and classroom talk through interactional sociolinguistics; no counts of lessons or interviews are given.
NUA's behaviour policy required that teachers and students 'must use correct standard English at all times and answer in full sentences', and that slang 'will be re-modelled and corrected by teachers'. Corridors were to be silent; one poster ended 'Speak in English only', though he observed pupils defying it. NUA's SLANT poster added 'in full sentences' to Lemov's routine, and he argues that TLAC's scripts de-skill teachers by policing their own talk. The closest analysis is of a 14-second clip from Lemov's TLAC video, not an NUA lesson, shown in NUA's assemblies and training, in which a teacher halts the pupil Shakir's eager answer at 'gots', a feature of African-American Vernacular English, and waits while a classmate whispers 'has'. Cushing argues this 'ends Shakir's enthusiastic willingness to engage', though in the transcript Shakir finishes the answer and is praised, and calls the technique, Format Matters, 'not just verbal hygiene, but verbal stigma'. His fieldnotes describe NUA teachers regularly disciplining pupils for non-standardised grammar and slang, the result often being pupils 'looking embarrassed, ashamed and unwilling to contribute further'. He proposes adding language to post-panoptic models of school surveillance.
He notes the data come from a single school, yet argues TLAC's popularity 'would strongly suggest' wider generalisability. The data are not shared.
The paper does not name psychological safety; the bridge is ours. We read it as showing how a rule about the form of speech can become a rule about who speaks, with standardised English made into classroom procedure.
Save this paper to a bibliography, keep notes on it, and export citations. Create a free account →
Related psychsafety.com articles (5)
- Body Language & Non-Verbal Communication
- Not Same for Everyone
- PS in Education
- Eye Contact & PS
- Verbally Speaking Up
