Psych Safety, by Iterum

The Case for Participation as Tyranny

Cooke & Kothari (2001) · Tyrannies of decision, group, method

Cooke & Kothari · Theoretical · Power & Equity, Critique & Boundary, Voice & Silence · Participation: The New Tyranny? · 2001 · Paywalled

Open this neighbourhood on the live map →

Bill Cooke and Uma Kothari's introduction to Participation: The New Tyranny? argues that participatory development, contrary to its rhetoric of empowerment, can be tyrannical, and that this potential is 'systemic, and not merely a matter of how the practitioner operates or the specificities of the techniques and tools employed'. Summing up the Collins dictionary entries, they define tyranny as 'the illegitimate and/or unjust exercise of power'.

The conference behind the book grew from a dissonance: in private, practitioners and participants often told, with mildly humorous cynicism, of participatory processes run ritualistically, turned manipulative, or harming those meant to be empowered, while Cooke and Kothari, as development workers, more often than not promoted the received wisdom. Their own humour, they came to feel, was a release valve that let them, and perhaps other practitioners, share worries while minimising them, which may have reflected a tacit anxiety about challenging practices to which major institutions, powerful people and good friends were committed.

Three tyrannies were named for that conference, each as a question: 'the tyranny of decision-making and control' (do facilitators override existing legitimate decision-making processes?), 'the tyranny of the group' (do group dynamics lead to decisions that reinforce the interests of the already powerful?) and the 'tyranny of method' (have participatory methods driven out others with advantages participation cannot provide?). The chapters, they write, suggest the answer to each is, or can be in some circumstances, yes, though the first two are more strongly addressed, or at least more explicitly stated, than the last.

The orthodoxy's own self-critique, they argue, is seen as a facet of the approach rather than a critique of it, and they ask whether methodological revisionism has obscured more fundamental problems. Across the chapters they find proponents generally 'naive about the complexities of power and power relations'. They resist being labelled anti-participation, leave open whether the tyrannical potential can be overcome, and call first for 'a genuine and rigorous reflexivity': any meaningful attempt to save participatory development requires accepting the possibility that it should not be saved. The chapter offers no data of its own.

It does not discuss psychological safety; the bridge is ours. We read the gap between private cynicism and public endorsement as voice withheld, perhaps, when a challenge would touch the powerful and one's friends, and the three questions as ones for any workplace practice that invites participation.

Cooke, B. and Kothari, U. (2001) 'The case for participation as tyranny', in Cooke, B. and Kothari, U. (eds) Participation: The New Tyranny? London and New York: Zed Books, pp. 1–15.

Save this paper to a bibliography, keep notes on it, and export citations. Create a free account →

Related psychsafety.com articles (4)

Related papers (3)

View the source paper →