Psych Safety, by Iterum

On Being Included: Racism and Diversity in Institutional Life

Ahmed (2012) · Diversity workers as institutional plumbers

Ahmed · Primary Research · Power & Equity, Culture & Context, Critique & Boundary · Duke University Press · 2012 · Paywalled

Open this neighbourhood on the live map →

Ahmed asks what diversity does, and what is being done when the language of diversity is used, questions she puts to diversity and equality practitioners in universities. She notes strong critiques of how the arrival of 'diversity' involves the departure of other, perhaps more critical, terms such as 'equality' and 'social justice', and asks whether the ease of its incorporation by institutions is a sign of the loss of its critical edge, while saying she is also interested in what diversity can and does do.

It is her first book to draw on qualitative empirical research: twenty-one interviews on diversity work in higher education, ten in Australia and eleven in the UK, 2003 to 2005 bar one in 2009. She also draws on meetings, conferences and her own work on a university race equality team. She calls the method perhaps 'an ethnography of texts' and says she cannot generalise her findings.

Chapter 1 takes from phenomenology the idea that to institutionalise something is for it to become routine, part of the background. Practitioners, she suggests, are given the goal of making diversity a goal, and an institutional aim to make diversity a goal can even be a sign that it is not one. Several interviewees used the phrase 'banging your head against a brick wall'; while habits save trouble, she writes, 'diversity work creates trouble'. She calls diversity workers 'institutional plumbers', expert in where things get stuck.

Building on Nirmal Puwar, she writes that an institutional norm is a 'somatic norm' when it takes the form of a white body; recruitment functions as a technology for reproducing whiteness. Following Les Back and Shona Hunter on the Macpherson definition's 'unwitting', she argues it can let individuals refuse responsibility, and that recognising institutional racism can easily become 'institutional therapy culture', as if admitting racism were a way of getting over it.

The Introduction says later chapters discuss the problems that follow when equality becomes a 'performance indicator', argue that statements of commitment are 'non-performatives' that 'do not bring about the effects they name', and consider diversity becoming a form of public relations. It is, she writes, as if having a policy becomes a substitute for action.

The bridge to psychological safety is ours. Ahmed recalls faculty meetings where she was the only person of colour: when a dean said something like 'race is too difficult to deal with', the difficulty of speaking about racism as a person of colour meant she spoke up after the meeting rather than during it, and wrote rather than spoke. His reply was do something about it; she answered that it should not be up to her. We read this as speaking up made harder for the person who stands out, and raising a problem as a way of being handed it.

Ahmed, S. (2012) On Being Included: Racism and Diversity in Institutional Life. Durham, NC and London: Duke University Press.

Save this paper to a bibliography, keep notes on it, and export citations. Create a free account →

Related psychsafety.com articles (5)

Related papers (3)

View the source paper →