Psych Safety, by Iterum

Epistemic Injustice: The Dog Has Now Been Removed From the Tail

Waites & Burnell (2023) · Reinterpretation, not retribution

Waites & Burnell · Commentary · Voice & Silence, Safety & Error, Power & Equity · HindSight · 2023 · Open access

Open this neighbourhood on the live map →

Joji Waites, of the British Airline Pilots' Association, and Captain James Burnell, a pilot and safety representative, argue that even in top-performing airlines there can be a barrier to safety reporting far stronger than fear of retribution. Reporters, they suggest, are perhaps deterred not 'by the lack of psychological safety created by a fear of retribution', nor by the process of investigation, 'but by the fact that their truth has the potential to be reinterpreted'.

Their case is one episode at an unnamed large company. Several pilots filed air safety reports about a new ground procedure that was putting pressure on them during turnarounds. The investigator reframed the last of these as 'a simple one-off error in the process', and a fifteen-year captain, emailing after the company's response, wrote that putting in an air safety report was a waste of time. The whole group gave up reporting the problem, the pilots created workarounds, and the issue was 'normalised into daily operations'; the company saw pilots getting used to a new procedure.

They call this epistemic injustice. The term comes with no source, and what they define is its opposite: epistemic justice is 'a term used to describe how power is used in defining the truth', and it means 'that the narrative and the interpreter of the truth must be the originator'. Safety professionals and managers, they say, often interpret events 'to fit the constraints of the reporting system (including the database)'. One likely reason, they suggest, is an engineering view of airline operations in which there is 'only one correct narrative'. Learning through narratives, they argue, can sit alongside the safety management system.

This is three pages of practitioner argument, with no data beyond that episode and their own experience. Their closing claim is offered as their experience: that 'the primary driver of a reluctance to report is not fear of retribution but epistemic injustice'. Psychological safety is named once, its lack tied to fear of retribution and their barrier set apart from it. We read that barrier as part of the same question, seen from the receiving end: what is done with a report can shape whether the next one seems worth filing.

Waites, J. and Burnell, J. (2023) 'Epistemic injustice: the dog has now been removed from the tail', HindSight, 35, pp. 18–20.

Save this paper to a bibliography, keep notes on it, and export citations. Create a free account →

Related psychsafety.com articles (5)

Related papers (4)

View the source paper →