Teams, tribes and patient safety: overcoming barriers to effective teamwork in healthcare
Weller, Boyd & Cumin (2014) · Professional tribes, seven-point plan
Jennifer Weller, Matt Boyd and David Cumin's review starts from the claim that much unintended patient harm is attributed to failures in communication between health professionals, and sorts the obstacles to information sharing into educational, psychological and organisational domains. Following Salas and colleagues, they hold that effective teams rest on mutual trust, closed-loop communication and shared mental models, and that information sharing is 'a fundamental requirement' for the last.
Training, they note, occurs largely within professional 'silos'. The psychological domain supplies the tribes of the title: drawing on social identity theory, they write that members of a professional group tend to see their own group's attributes as positive and other groups' as less desirable. Hierarchy is a further barrier, since 'less senior staff may not feel they can challenge decisions or offer suggestions or alternative diagnoses and so may conceal their concerns'. Organisationally, junior doctors describe coordinating care across multiple wards and staff by relying on 'opportunistic meetings'.
The evidence is drawn from other studies, such as Mazzocco and colleagues' finding of more than double the risk of surgical complications where teams shared patient information less often at the start of a case and at handover. The seven-point plan: teach structured communication such as SBAR; train teams together; train them with simulation; define inclusive teams; create democratic teams 'where all members are confident of being heard'; support teamwork with protocols such as checklists and briefings; and develop a supporting organisational culture. Much of this, they argue, is about 'creating conditions that prompt, reward or facilitate appropriate behaviours'.
The review was commissioned and externally peer reviewed, focuses predominantly on hospital teams, states no search method, and lists elucidating the association between patient harm and failures in teamwork among its current research questions.
The paper does not use the term psychological safety. The bridge is ours: we read its less senior staff who may conceal concerns as the interpersonal risk that psychological safety names, its democratic teams where all members are confident of being heard as that risk lowered, and its seven actions as ways of lowering it.
Save this paper to a bibliography, keep notes on it, and export citations. Create a free account →
Related psychsafety.com articles (5)
- Crew Resource Mgmt
- The Tenerife Disaster
- Psychological Safety in Healthcare
- Reducing Power Gradients
- PACE Assertiveness
Related papers (3)
- Haynes et al. (2009): A Surgical Safety Checklist to Reduce Morbidity and Mortality in a Global Population
- Sutcliffe, Lewton & Rosenthal (2004): Communication Failures: An Insidious Contributor to Medical Mishaps
- Sexton, Thomas & Helmreich (2000): Error, stress, and teamwork in medicine and aviation: cross sectional surveys
