Psych Safety, by Iterum

Look Me in the Eyes: Constraining Gaze in the Eye-Region Provokes Abnormally High Subcortical Activation in Autism

Hadjikhani et al (2017) · Constrained gaze, subcortical response

Hadjikhani et al · Primary Research · Trust & Interpersonal, Power & Equity · Scientific Reports · 2017 · Open access

Open this neighbourhood on the live map →

Hadjikhani and colleagues used functional MRI to test whether directing autistic people's gaze to the eye region changes activity in a subcortical pathway for rapid face processing: the superior colliculus, the pulvinar nucleus of the thalamus and the amygdala. They report that it does, and that the response 'may be at the basis of their eye avoidance in daily life'. Against accounts reading reduced eye contact as indifference, they cite first-hand reports suggesting the problem may be one of 'socio-affective oversensitivity'.

Twenty-three autistic participants and 20 controls, children and adults aged 10 to 42, matched for age and IQ, all of normal intelligence and mostly male, watched identical five-second clips of faces turning fearful, happy or angry, and moving neutral faces, in two counterbalanced runs: once viewing freely, once with a red cross in the eye region to fixate.

A four-way interaction of group, emotion, condition and region was significant (p = 0.038, partial eta squared 0.051). In the superior colliculus and both amygdalae the groups had the same activation when viewing freely, but under constraint the autistic group showed what the paper calls 'abnormally high' activation relative to controls, for neutral and emotional faces alike. Pulvinar activation was higher in the autistic group in both conditions, except for angry faces under constraint. Within the autistic group, constraint had its strongest effect in the amygdalae. Group differences were largest for fear, yet the free versus constrained difference was also 'remarkable' for happy faces, which they read as over-reaction to positive as well as threat-related stimuli.

They name four limits: no eye-tracking in the scanner, so activation was never related to time spent on the eyes; constrained gaze was tested only with faces, so part of the effect may come from constraining gaze in general; no study, this one included, has linked reported discomfort to the neural pattern; and only participants of normal intelligence took part. We add that the groups are small. Forcing autistic people to look in the eyes during behavioural therapy 'might be counterproductive and elicit more anxiety', they suggest, though they also hold that not looking misses social information, and offer gradual habituation as one possible strategy.

The paper does not mention psychological safety; the bridge is ours. We read it as a reason to doubt that an instruction to hold eye contact costs everyone the same, while noting that it measured brain activation, not stress or discomfort while looking.

Hadjikhani, N., Åsberg Johnels, J., Zürcher, N.R., Lassalle, A., Guillon, Q., Hippolyte, L., Billstedt, E., Ward, N., Lemonnier, E. and Gillberg, C. (2017) 'Look me in the eyes: constraining gaze in the eye-region provokes abnormally high subcortical activation in autism', Scientific Reports, 7, 3163.

Save this paper to a bibliography, keep notes on it, and export citations. Create a free account →

Related psychsafety.com articles (4)

Related papers (2)

View the source paper →