How do adults and teens with self-declared Autism Spectrum Disorder experience eye contact? A qualitative analysis of first-hand accounts
Trevisan et al (2017) · Self-declared autistic accounts of gaze
Trevisan, Roberts, Lin and Birmingham ask how people with self-declared autism experience eye contact, and answer from what such people had already said in public, not from a laboratory task. The data are secondhand: 10 YouTube videos found with the search terms 'autism' and 'eye contact', accepted only where the speaker disclosed a diagnosis (the paper does not say how many results were screened), and 1,424 posts by 768 users in 62 eye contact threads on WrongPlanet.net, whose members 'identify as having ASD', as of April 2016. From the forum, 623 passages by 354 users were coded, 249 of whom contributed one; with the videos, 698 'meaning units' from 364 people were sorted by qualitative content analysis into eight themes.
Five themes describe the experience itself: adverse reactions, from fear and pain to nausea and a 'fight or flight' response; invasion, eye contact felt as violation, exposure or an intimacy fit only for loved ones; what they interpret as sensory overload, above all difficulty taking in sight and sound at once, such as being unable to listen while looking, the largest subtheme at 81 units; confusion over social nuances such as how long to hold a gaze; and difficulty reading and sending non-verbal signals. Without setting out to test theories, they find the data most strongly support the hyperarousal model, with less, and that tentatively, for hypoarousal, and some for mindblindness, and present the listening difficulty and the sense of invasion as novel findings. In 29 units people described childhood pressure to make eye contact as traumatic, and were 'all but unanimously critical' of such interventions. Reported strategies leaned to compensating rather than improving, chiefly looking at the face but not the eyes.
They state the limits: diagnosis could not be verified; posters are unlikely to represent the autistic population; people distressed by eye contact are probably over-represented; there was no member-checking; and it is unknown whether the themes are distinct experiences or different ways of describing the same phenomena. The title and abstract name teens, but the paper reports no ages.
The bridge is ours. We read the paper as first-hand testimony that for some people being looked at is felt as threat, intrusion or a load that crowds out listening, so an instruction to hold eye contact as a sign of attention can cost the concentration it is meant to show. The theme counts are of passages, not people, and the paper's vocabulary is clinical, of 'disorder' and 'deficits'; it cannot show how common these experiences are, or that less eye contact makes anyone safer.
Save this paper to a bibliography, keep notes on it, and export citations. Create a free account →
Related psychsafety.com articles (5)
- Body Language & Non-Verbal Communication
- The Case for Less Eye Contact
- Not Feeling Seen
- PS & Neurodiversity
- Eye Contact & PS
