The Seductions of Quantification: Measuring Human Rights, Gender Violence, and Sex Trafficking
Merry (2016) · Expertise inertia and data inertia
Merry's book asks, in the words of its first chapter, 'how the production and use of global indicators are shaped by inequalities in power and expertise'. Quantification is seductive, she argues there, because numbers offer simple, comparable knowledge of a murky world and 'convey an aura of objective truth and scientific authority despite the extensive interpretive work that goes into their construction'. Her focus is not on the accuracy of indicators but on the social and political processes that produce them, and on their effects on governance.
The book traces the genealogy of three global indicators: measures of violence against women, the US State Department's Trafficking in Persons Reports, and the human rights indicators of the UN Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights. The first chapter describes six years of ethnographic field research, including meetings, workshops and interviews with the major players in each initiative, alongside the documentary record and fieldwork by three of Merry's graduate students.
The chapter sets out the framework. Indicators have both a knowledge effect and a governance effect. Merry names 'expertise inertia', in which insiders with experience have a greater say than those without, 'a pattern that excludes the inexperienced and powerless', and 'data inertia', in which existing data determine what an indicator can measure; together, she argues, they relegate those with local knowledge to the sidelines. Indicators sometimes fail to produce objective knowledge in at least two ways, through false specificity and, a second possible reason, by camouflaging the political considerations that shape the collection and presentation of data. A page later she writes that 'The technical is always political', and 'The political hides behind the technical.'
She does not dismiss numbers. Numerical knowledge is 'essential', indicators offer a more reliable basis for decisions than ignorance or prejudice, and governance by indicators can open decisions to public scrutiny as well as reinforce inequality. Her case is for grounding indicators in qualitative knowledge and for 'indicator literacy'. Her three cases are global indicators that compare countries, not teams or organisations.
The bridge to psychological safety is ours. The chapter's opening contrast, in which fourteen survivors of domestic violence interviewed seventy-five others about New York City's family courts and reported problems that the OHCHR indicators did not measure, and a line in its conclusions, that 'Those who are measured typically lack a voice in the construction of the categories and measurements', we read as a caution for any team survey whose questions are written without the team.
Save this paper to a bibliography, keep notes on it, and export citations. Create a free account →
Related psychsafety.com articles (5)
- Principles of Ethical Measurement
- Beyond Metrics
- Goodhart's / Cobra Effect
- Measuring Inequality
- Streetlight Effect
Related papers (4)
- Scott (1998): Seeing Like a State: How Certain Schemes to Improve the Human Condition Have Failed
- Ridgway (1956): Dysfunctional Consequences of Performance Measurements
- Espeland & Sauder (2007): Rankings and Reactivity: How Public Measures Recreate Social Worlds
- Tsoukas (1997): The Tyranny of Light: The Temptations and the Paradoxes of the Information Society
