Psych Safety, by Iterum

Thick as Thieves: The Effects of Ethical Orientation and Psychological Safety on Unethical Team Behavior

Pearsall & Ellis (2011) · Safe utilitarian teams cheat more

Pearsall & Ellis · Primary Research · Critique & Boundary, Voice & Silence · Journal of Applied Psychology · 2011 · Paywalled

Open this neighbourhood on the live map →

Pearsall and Ellis test whether psychological safety can help a team act unethically. A collective unethical decision, they argue, needs one or more members to raise the idea and others to agree openly, which is risky, so for teams high in utilitarianism psychological safety 'provides a mechanism through which intent may be transformed into collective, unethical action'. Utilitarianism here is an ethical orientation that judges a decision by its outcomes and consequences; formalism relies on precedent, norms and rules.

The sample was 378 undergraduates in a management class at a United States university, randomly assigned to 126 three-member teams for a 14-week semester. Ethical orientations were averaged within each team, and psychological safety was measured after 10 weeks with Edmondson's (1999) seven-item scale. In week 11 each team answered a hypothetical scenario about using an old project from a friend's files. In week 13 teams graded their own final case assignment, worth 2% of the final grade, against eight required points; one was a decoy unrelated to the case, and a team that claimed credit for it was coded as cheating.

In logistic regressions team utilitarianism predicted both the decision to cheat (odds ratio 5.23) and cheating behaviour (4.11). Formalism was negatively related to the hypothetical decision, but not significantly to behaviour. The interaction of utilitarianism with psychological safety was significant for cheating behaviour (odds ratio 31.60, p < .05) and reached only p < .10 for the scenario decision; Pearsall and Ellis report their hypothesis as supported. Psychological safety also had a direct positive relationship with cheating behaviour (odds ratio 6.70 before the interaction was entered), though not with the scenario decision. Moral accommodation, members going along with the group against their own inclinations, 'may potentially explain' this.

They present the result as 'a potentially important boundary condition' on the benefits of psychological safety. They hold that its many benefits 'clearly outweigh the potential cost', and that if managers model ethical conduct the negative effects 'might be reduced'.

Interactions within the teams were not monitored or measured, so the proposed mechanism, a member raising the idea of cheating, was inferred rather than observed. The teams were small and without formal leaders, and their members relatively young. Classroom cheating is generally viewed as innocuous, which they call 'an important boundary condition': the influence of ethical orientations may be very different for behaviour that entails more potential harm to others, and results 'may be very different outside of a university setting'.

Pearsall, M.J. and Ellis, A.P.J. (2011) 'Thick as thieves: the effects of ethical orientation and psychological safety on unethical team behavior', Journal of Applied Psychology, 96(2), pp. 401–411.

Save this paper to a bibliography, keep notes on it, and export citations. Create a free account →

Related psychsafety.com articles (4)

Related papers (6)

View the source paper →