Psych Safety, by Iterum

Panoptic Performativity and School Inspection Regimes: Disciplinary Mechanisms and Life under Special Measures

Perryman (2006) · Performing for the inspector

Perryman · Case Study · Critique & Boundary, Power & Equity, Measurement & Method · Journal of Education Policy · 2006 · Open access

Open this neighbourhood on the live map →

Perryman proposes 'panoptic performativity' for what intensive school inspection does to teachers: a regime in which the frequency of inspection and the sense of being perpetually under surveillance lead teachers to perform in ways dictated by the discourse of inspection, in order to escape the regime. She builds it from Foucault on the Panopticon and normalisation and Lyotard's performativity, against school effectiveness research that she argues Ofsted adopted wholesale to judge every school irrespective of socio-economic context.

The case is Northgate, a pseudonymous inner-city comprehensive of about 700 pupils, 53 per cent entitled to free school meals, in Special Measures for just under two years; the study ran from 1999 to 2003. Perryman reports interviewing the thirteen teachers, of around forty, who had been there when it went in, during Special Measures and again the following year, when ten remained. She also traces the school's self-evaluations against its inspection reports, and quotes pupils.

The school was inspected eight times in eighteen months and five times in nine months during one intense phase, and staff learnt to act as if inspection were continuous, describing a 'treadmill' and 'jumping through hoops'. The head teacher's first report ran to five typed sides, the ninth to 47 spiral bound pages, increasingly in the inspectors' own language. Lessons ran to a strict formula, monitored by senior managers, and teachers, Perryman says, treated it all as a temporary way out. A senior manager said they would 'play the game', and that 'We don't take risks which is hampering our rate of progress'; middle managers said they could not experiment while in Special Measures.

On its own terms the regime worked: after about two years the school left Special Measures, and Perryman accepts that it had needed intervention. Her doubt is about what the performance leaves behind. She argues that fear of the regime leaves schools making changes that can often be short-term and cosmetic, suggests the disempowerment perhaps indicates why schools can sometimes decline once released, and closes on questions, asking whether the normalisation is truly internalised. The evidence is one school and the staff who stayed, most of them managers, and the paper leaves what happened after release to Perryman's separate follow-up.

The paper does not mention psychological safety; the bridge is ours. We read Northgate as staff performing for their observer, where constant evaluation, by its managers' account, narrowed what the school would risk or try, and as a caution that evaluation made often enough, against a fixed picture of good practice, may teach people to perform to it.

Perryman, J. (2006) 'Panoptic performativity and school inspection regimes: disciplinary mechanisms and life under special measures', Journal of Education Policy, 21(2), pp. 147–161.

Save this paper to a bibliography, keep notes on it, and export citations. Create a free account →

Related psychsafety.com articles (3)

Related papers (4)

View the source paper →