Enviable Support: How and When Advantageous Voice Endorsement Fosters Employee Silence
A finding that should unsettle anyone who treats visible leader support for speaking up as an unmixed good. Song and colleagues examine advantageous voice endorsement, an employee's perception that their own suggestions are backed by the manager more often than their coworkers' are, and find it increases that employee's silence afterwards. The mechanism they propose and test is not fear of the boss but concern about being envied by peers. Drawing on the sensitivity about being the target of a threatening upward comparison model, they argue that a visibly favoured employee reads themselves as the object of an unwelcome comparison, anticipates resentment, and withholds later input as a kind of self-deprecation, dimming their own advantage to keep the peace. Silence here is a relational strategy aimed sideways at colleagues rather than upward at power. The evidence is unusually thorough for one paper. A preregistered vignette experiment on Prolific, 194 analysed, produced a large effect on concern about being envied. Three lagged field studies followed: China, 133 public administration employees across two waves, then the United States and the United Kingdom with three waves each and 333 analysed in the American sample. The moderator is superficial harmony, a disposition to avoid disrupting relationships in order to protect oneself. Where it is high the indirect path to silence holds; where it is low the path is not significant at all. For this corpus the most important result is one the authors treat as a control. Psychological safety was measured as a rival mediator and did not carry the effect. In the Chinese sample advantageous endorsement was unrelated to psychological safety, psychological safety was unrelated to silence, and the indirect path through it was not significant. In the larger samples psychological safety sat alongside voice self-efficacy, fear and pride as alternative mechanisms the authors report as ruled out, although there advantageous endorsement did predict lower psychological safety, so the construct is not untouched, merely not the route to silence. The same data separate voice from silence as constructs: concern about being envied predicted silence but not voice, while psychological safety and voice self-efficacy predicted voice but not silence. This is a road into silence running outside the conditions psychological safety describes, which is a genuine boundary rather than a quibble. Hold the size of it lightly. Everything is self-reported, which the authors defend on the grounds that a perception, an internal state and a deliberate withholding are all poorly observed from outside, and they separate measurement in time rather than in source. Advantageous endorsement is operationalised three ways across the studies, converging but not identically. And the standardised indirect effect is 0.35 in the smallest study against 0.07 and 0.05 in the two larger and better designed ones, so the mediated path is real but modest where the design is strongest. The practical advice, that managers should aim for rough balance when endorsing ideas of comparable quality, follows from the mechanism rather than from any tested intervention.
Save this paper to a bibliography, keep notes on it, and export citations. Create a free account →
Neighbours (11)
- Conceptualizing Employee Silence and Employee Voice as Multidimensional Constructs
- Distinguishing Voice and Silence at Work: Unique Relationships with Perceived Impact, Psychological Safety, and Burnout
- Employee Voice and Silence
- Strategies for Learning from Failure
- Affect- and Cognition-Based Trust as Foundations for Interpersonal Cooperation in Organizations
- An Exploratory Study of Employee Silence: Issues That Employees Don't Communicate Upward and Why
- Employee Silence: Quiescence and Acquiescence as Responses to Perceived Injustice
- Silenced by Fear: The Nature, Sources, and Consequences of Fear at Work
- Psychological Antecedents of Promotive and Prohibitive Voice: A Two-Wave Examination
- Speaking Up at Work
- Types of Silence