The Risks and Rewards of Speaking Up: Managerial Responses to Employee Voice
Burris (2012) · Challenging versus supportive voice
Ethan Burris asks how managers actually respond when employees speak up, not how employees expect them to, and argues that it depends on the type of voice. Challenging voice seeks to 'alter, modify, or destabilize' accepted practices, policies or strategy; supportive voice is 'intended to stabilize or preserve' them. Both, he argues, are prosocial efforts to benefit the organisation, but challenging voice is likely to meet resistance; he proposes perceived loyalty and personal threat as the mechanisms.
In Study 1, 281 restaurant store managers reported their own voice towards their district managers, who rated their performance. In a multilevel model with controls, challenging voice was negatively related to performance ratings and supportive voice positively; challenging voice's simple correlation was not significant, a shift Burris puts down especially to controlling for supportive voice. In Study 2, 45 MBA students and professionals, in a manager's role, rated one employee who challenged a bus route plan and one who backed it: the challenger was rated a poorer performer, less loyal and more threatening, and his ideas were endorsed less. In Study 3, 51 four-person student teams chose a supply strategy under a randomly chosen leader; one member of each was given objectively correct information that the favoured strategy was worse and told to challenge it. The more a member argued that case, the lower the leader's promotion rating and endorsement; more supportive voice went with higher promotion ratings.
In both experiments perceived loyalty mediated the effect of voice type on performance ratings, and perceived threat its effect on endorsement (in Study 2 loyalty also mediated endorsement). Burris suggests managers may weigh motives when deciding whom to reward, and personal impact when deciding which ideas to endorse. Experts were rated more favourably overall, but expert status produced no significant interaction with challenging voice on any outcome, so 'experts are not immune', evidence he calls preliminary.
He names the limits: Study 1 is cross-sectional and open to reverse causality; Study 2 is hypothetical and always presented the challenger first; challenging practices could not be separated from challenging the manager's own choices; style and tone were not studied; and the outcomes were subjective evaluations, so challenging voice might still improve objective ones.
The paper does not name psychological safety. It notes that employees may judge speaking up 'safe and worthwhile' when managers may not respond accordingly, and reads Study 1 as suggesting 'some reality to those risks, but only for those engaging in challenging voice'. The bridge is ours: we read it as evidence that, for challenging voice, the interpersonal risk psychological safety concerns is partly the real response of the person spoken to.
Save this paper to a bibliography, keep notes on it, and export citations. Create a free account →
Related psychsafety.com articles (5)
Related papers (13)
- Van Dyne, Ang & Botero (2003): Conceptualizing Employee Silence and Employee Voice as Multidimensional Constructs
- Milliken et al (2003): An Exploratory Study of Employee Silence: Issues That Employees Don't Communicate Upward and Why
- Detert & Burris (2007): Leadership Behavior and Employee Voice: Is the Door Really Open?
- Morrison & Milliken (2000): Organizational Silence: A Barrier to Change and Development in a Pluralistic World
- Morrison (2011): Employee Voice Behavior: Integration and Directions for Future Research
- Detert & Edmondson (2011): Implicit Voice Theories: Taken-for-Granted Rules of Self-Censorship at Work
- Liang, Farh & Farh (2012): Psychological Antecedents of Promotive and Prohibitive Voice: A Two-Wave Examination
- Burris et al (2008): Quitting Before Leaving: The Mediating Effects of Psychological Attachment and Detachment on Voice
- Song et al (2026): Enviable Support: How and When Advantageous Voice Endorsement Fosters Employee Silence
- Fast, Burris & Bartel (2014): Managing to Stay in the Dark: Managerial Self-Efficacy, Ego Defensiveness, and the Aversion to Employee Voice
- Ashford et al (1998): Out on a Limb: The Role of Context and Impression Management in Selling Gender-Equity Issues
- Dutton et al (1997): Reading the Wind: How Middle Managers Assess the Context for Selling Issues to Top Managers
- Howell et al (2015): Who Gets Credit for Input? Demographic and Structural Status Cues in Voice Recognition
