Managing to Stay in the Dark: Managerial Self-Efficacy, Ego Defensiveness, and the Aversion to Employee Voice
Fast, Burris & Bartel (2014) · Insecure managers shun voice
Nathanael Fast, Ethan Burris and Caroline Bartel ask why some managers are averse to improvement-oriented voice. They propose that managers with low managerial self-efficacy, a low perceived ability to meet the elevated competence expectations of the role, seek to minimise voice 'as a way of compensating for a threatened ego'. Role theory supplies the pressure on managers to demonstrate competence; self-discrepancy theory supplies the threat when they feel unable to meet it. They study voice aversion in three forms: soliciting less input, evaluating negatively those who speak up, and implementing fewer ideas.
Study 1 matched 148 employees to 41 managers in four divisions of a multinational oil and gas organisation. In multilevel models with controls, managers' self-rated efficacy was positively related to employees' reports of being asked for input (t = 2.13, p < .05) and to their voice (t = 2.52, p < .05); with solicitation entered, efficacy no longer predicted voice, and the bootstrapped confidence interval for the indirect effect through solicitation excluded zero. The raw correlation of efficacy with solicitation was not significant (r = .08); they raise possible statistical suppression. The data are correlational: low efficacy could follow from little voice.
Study 2 gave 131 adults a vignette as an airline manager whose plan a maintenance chief challenges, crossing a low or high efficacy manipulation with self-affirmation (writing about their most important value). Without affirmation, the low efficacy condition was less willing to solicit input (5.07 against 5.89 on a seven-point scale), rated the employee less competent and was less willing to implement his suggestions; with affirmation the differences were not significant. They did not measure ego threat, since people may not admit to it and asking could reveal the study's purpose, and infer from the interactions (p = .05, .01, .02) that ego defensiveness drove the effects. They grant the vignette compromises external validity.
The paper names psychological safety, citing Edmondson (1999) and others for the point that where leaders foster it 'members feel freer to take risks, propose changes, and learn from mistakes', and suggest, untested here, that a climate marked by it 'could increase the tendency for managers who lack managerial self-efficacy to solicit voice'. They conclude that voice 'appears to be particularly risky when it could be most beneficial'. We read this as turning the question round: the manager on whom employees' safety depends may be the one who feels threatened.
Save this paper to a bibliography, keep notes on it, and export citations. Create a free account →
Related psychsafety.com articles (5)
- Calculus of Voice
- Being Approachable
- Building PS Upwards
- Interpersonal & Existential Threats
- Bad Management
Related papers (12)
- Edmondson (1999): Psychological Safety and Learning Behavior in Work Teams
- Milliken et al (2003): An Exploratory Study of Employee Silence: Issues That Employees Don't Communicate Upward and Why
- Detert & Burris (2007): Leadership Behavior and Employee Voice: Is the Door Really Open?
- Morrison & Milliken (2000): Organizational Silence: A Barrier to Change and Development in a Pluralistic World
- Magee & Galinsky (2008): Social Hierarchy: The Self-Reinforcing Nature of Power and Status
- Ashford et al (2009): Speaking Up and Speaking Out: The Leadership Dynamics of Voice in Organizations
- Morrison (2011): Employee Voice Behavior: Integration and Directions for Future Research
- Detert & Edmondson (2011): Implicit Voice Theories: Taken-for-Granted Rules of Self-Censorship at Work
- Walumbwa & Schaubroeck (2009): Leader Personality Traits and Employee Voice Behavior: Mediating Roles of Ethical Leadership and Work Group Psychological Safety
- Nembhard & Edmondson (2006): Making it Safe: The Effects of Leader Inclusiveness and Professional Status on Psychological Safety and Improvement Efforts in Health Care Teams
- Burris et al (2008): Quitting Before Leaving: The Mediating Effects of Psychological Attachment and Detachment on Voice
- Burris (2012): The Risks and Rewards of Speaking Up: Managerial Responses to Employee Voice
