Psych Safety, by Iterum

Implementing New Practices: An Empirical Study of Organizational Learning in Hospital Intensive Care Units

Tucker, Nembhard & Edmondson (2007) · Learn-how versus learn-what

Tucker, Nembhard & Edmondson · Primary Research · Team Learning, Culture & Context · Management Science · 2007 · Paywalled

Open this neighbourhood on the live map →

Anita Tucker, Ingrid Nembhard and Amy Edmondson ask how improvement project teams in neonatal intensive care units identify, adapt and spread new practices, drawing on best practice transfer, team learning and process change. They separate learn-what, activities that identify current best practices, from learn-how, activities that operationalise practices in a given setting, and find that of the two only learn-how was associated with implementation success.

The setting was a 2002 collaborative of 44 NICUs. Interviews in four units yielded 12 learning activities; 23 of the other 40 units were surveyed, with 1,440 responses, 265 from project members rating their team's use of each. Factor analysis grouped staff feedback before implementation, soliciting staff ideas, education sessions, project team meetings, pilot runs and Plan-Do-Study-Act cycles as learn-how, and distributing articles, literature reviews, site visits and conference calls with other units as learn-what. Level of evidence came from the collaborative's Muir Gray ratings; the outcome was perceived implementation success at unit level.

Psychological safety, a work unit in which members believe they can question existing practices, raise concerns or dissent and admit mistakes without ridicule or punishment, was measured with three items modified from Edmondson's 1999 scale, on checking with each other how to do something, valuing others' skills and talents, and bringing up problems and tough issues. To limit inflated correlations, success ratings came from nurses outside project teams and activity data from project members; psychological safety was rated by nurses outside project teams in some models and by project members in others.

Stronger supporting evidence for a unit's portfolio of projects was associated with implementation success, as was learn-how; learn-what was not. Psychological safety was associated with learn-how, which mediated between it and success. Because learn-how activities involve interpersonal risk, they argue, a climate of psychological safety may play an important role in implementing improved practices.

They caution that the evidence result cannot prove causality, that learn-what's effect may have been undetectable in a sample of 23 units, whose teams had already done much learn-what at collaborative meetings, and that future studies must tease apart whether psychological safety enables learn-how or results from it. Units self-selected into the collaborative, and success was perceived, not objectively measured. They also note that the results are most relevant to health care and may apply best to other long-term collaborative settings. Most prior work measured psychological safety at team level; here it was measured across the whole unit, and they suggest future research may need to consider it at organisational level.

Tucker, A.L., Nembhard, I.M. and Edmondson, A.C. (2007) 'Implementing new practices: An empirical study of organizational learning in hospital intensive care units', Management Science, 53(6), pp. 894–907.

The Long Shift, a Learning Lab session on the care of Jack Adcock at Leicester Royal Infirmary (2011), draws on this paper: run it with your team. Open the Learning Lab →

Save this paper to a bibliography, keep notes on it, and export citations. Create a free account →

Related psychsafety.com articles (3)

Related papers (20)

View the source paper →